A first step towards bringing (European) containment simulations to a common level

St. Kelm, Ph. Broxtermann, S. Krajewski, H.-J. Allelein, G. Preusser, M. Sangiorgi, W. Klein-Hessling, I. Bakalov, A. Bleyer, A. Bentaib, I. Kljenak, M. Stempniewicz, J.R. Jonnet, P. Kostka, S. Morandi, J. Burkhardt, L. Denk, Z. Parduba, S. Paci, A. ManfrediniAri Silde, J. Jancovic, P. Juris

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientific

    Abstract

    One outcome of the OECD/NEA ISP-47 (TOSQAN, MISTRA, THAI) activity was the recommendation to elaborate a 'Generic Containment' including all important components. On the one hand, this Generic Containment will help to rate analyses being performed with different lumped-parameter models. On the other hand, it can serve as a basis for testing new model developments on a commonly available and accepted basis. Within the SARNET2 Network of Excellence, such a Generic Containment nodalisation, based on a German PWR 1300 MWel, has been developed and is applied for a lumped parameter code-to-code comparison with increasing complexity. The initial benchmark step, 'Generic Containment-run-0', considered a strongly simplified SB LOCA transient in order to have a clear basis for the preparation of the inputs, their verification and to investigate the transferability of assumptions and specifications among different codes. Within the current step of the benchmark exercise, run-1, a more detailed evaluation is performed in order to achieve an understanding of the basic differences among the codes and models and the resulting deviations. This includes an identification and reduction of the user-dependent impact. This paper summarises the initial benchmark step run-0 and gives an outlook to the results of the current run-1, which is expected to be finished in mid 2012.
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationERMSAR 2012 Papers (CD)
    Publication statusPublished - 2012
    MoE publication typeNot Eligible
    Event5th European Review Meeting on Severe Accident Research, ERMSAR 2012 - Cologne, Germany
    Duration: 21 Mar 201223 Mar 2012

    Conference

    Conference5th European Review Meeting on Severe Accident Research, ERMSAR 2012
    Abbreviated titleERMSAR 2012
    CountryGermany
    CityCologne
    Period21/03/1223/03/12

    Fingerprint

    Loss of coolant accidents
    Identification (control systems)
    Specifications
    Testing

    Cite this

    Kelm, S., Broxtermann, P., Krajewski, S., Allelein, H-J., Preusser, G., Sangiorgi, M., ... Juris, P. (2012). A first step towards bringing (European) containment simulations to a common level. In ERMSAR 2012 Papers (CD)
    Kelm, St. ; Broxtermann, Ph. ; Krajewski, S. ; Allelein, H.-J. ; Preusser, G. ; Sangiorgi, M. ; Klein-Hessling, W. ; Bakalov, I. ; Bleyer, A. ; Bentaib, A. ; Kljenak, I. ; Stempniewicz, M. ; Jonnet, J.R. ; Kostka, P. ; Morandi, S. ; Burkhardt, J. ; Denk, L. ; Parduba, Z. ; Paci, S. ; Manfredini, A. ; Silde, Ari ; Jancovic, J. ; Juris, P. / A first step towards bringing (European) containment simulations to a common level. ERMSAR 2012 Papers (CD). 2012.
    @inproceedings{469c3470ccf84b22b9079a576401fc26,
    title = "A first step towards bringing (European) containment simulations to a common level",
    abstract = "One outcome of the OECD/NEA ISP-47 (TOSQAN, MISTRA, THAI) activity was the recommendation to elaborate a 'Generic Containment' including all important components. On the one hand, this Generic Containment will help to rate analyses being performed with different lumped-parameter models. On the other hand, it can serve as a basis for testing new model developments on a commonly available and accepted basis. Within the SARNET2 Network of Excellence, such a Generic Containment nodalisation, based on a German PWR 1300 MWel, has been developed and is applied for a lumped parameter code-to-code comparison with increasing complexity. The initial benchmark step, 'Generic Containment-run-0', considered a strongly simplified SB LOCA transient in order to have a clear basis for the preparation of the inputs, their verification and to investigate the transferability of assumptions and specifications among different codes. Within the current step of the benchmark exercise, run-1, a more detailed evaluation is performed in order to achieve an understanding of the basic differences among the codes and models and the resulting deviations. This includes an identification and reduction of the user-dependent impact. This paper summarises the initial benchmark step run-0 and gives an outlook to the results of the current run-1, which is expected to be finished in mid 2012.",
    author = "St. Kelm and Ph. Broxtermann and S. Krajewski and H.-J. Allelein and G. Preusser and M. Sangiorgi and W. Klein-Hessling and I. Bakalov and A. Bleyer and A. Bentaib and I. Kljenak and M. Stempniewicz and J.R. Jonnet and P. Kostka and S. Morandi and J. Burkhardt and L. Denk and Z. Parduba and S. Paci and A. Manfredini and Ari Silde and J. Jancovic and P. Juris",
    year = "2012",
    language = "English",
    booktitle = "ERMSAR 2012 Papers (CD)",

    }

    Kelm, S, Broxtermann, P, Krajewski, S, Allelein, H-J, Preusser, G, Sangiorgi, M, Klein-Hessling, W, Bakalov, I, Bleyer, A, Bentaib, A, Kljenak, I, Stempniewicz, M, Jonnet, JR, Kostka, P, Morandi, S, Burkhardt, J, Denk, L, Parduba, Z, Paci, S, Manfredini, A, Silde, A, Jancovic, J & Juris, P 2012, A first step towards bringing (European) containment simulations to a common level. in ERMSAR 2012 Papers (CD). 5th European Review Meeting on Severe Accident Research, ERMSAR 2012, Cologne, Germany, 21/03/12.

    A first step towards bringing (European) containment simulations to a common level. / Kelm, St.; Broxtermann, Ph.; Krajewski, S.; Allelein, H.-J.; Preusser, G.; Sangiorgi, M.; Klein-Hessling, W.; Bakalov, I.; Bleyer, A.; Bentaib, A.; Kljenak, I.; Stempniewicz, M.; Jonnet, J.R.; Kostka, P.; Morandi, S.; Burkhardt, J.; Denk, L.; Parduba, Z.; Paci, S.; Manfredini, A.; Silde, Ari; Jancovic, J.; Juris, P.

    ERMSAR 2012 Papers (CD). 2012.

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientific

    TY - GEN

    T1 - A first step towards bringing (European) containment simulations to a common level

    AU - Kelm, St.

    AU - Broxtermann, Ph.

    AU - Krajewski, S.

    AU - Allelein, H.-J.

    AU - Preusser, G.

    AU - Sangiorgi, M.

    AU - Klein-Hessling, W.

    AU - Bakalov, I.

    AU - Bleyer, A.

    AU - Bentaib, A.

    AU - Kljenak, I.

    AU - Stempniewicz, M.

    AU - Jonnet, J.R.

    AU - Kostka, P.

    AU - Morandi, S.

    AU - Burkhardt, J.

    AU - Denk, L.

    AU - Parduba, Z.

    AU - Paci, S.

    AU - Manfredini, A.

    AU - Silde, Ari

    AU - Jancovic, J.

    AU - Juris, P.

    PY - 2012

    Y1 - 2012

    N2 - One outcome of the OECD/NEA ISP-47 (TOSQAN, MISTRA, THAI) activity was the recommendation to elaborate a 'Generic Containment' including all important components. On the one hand, this Generic Containment will help to rate analyses being performed with different lumped-parameter models. On the other hand, it can serve as a basis for testing new model developments on a commonly available and accepted basis. Within the SARNET2 Network of Excellence, such a Generic Containment nodalisation, based on a German PWR 1300 MWel, has been developed and is applied for a lumped parameter code-to-code comparison with increasing complexity. The initial benchmark step, 'Generic Containment-run-0', considered a strongly simplified SB LOCA transient in order to have a clear basis for the preparation of the inputs, their verification and to investigate the transferability of assumptions and specifications among different codes. Within the current step of the benchmark exercise, run-1, a more detailed evaluation is performed in order to achieve an understanding of the basic differences among the codes and models and the resulting deviations. This includes an identification and reduction of the user-dependent impact. This paper summarises the initial benchmark step run-0 and gives an outlook to the results of the current run-1, which is expected to be finished in mid 2012.

    AB - One outcome of the OECD/NEA ISP-47 (TOSQAN, MISTRA, THAI) activity was the recommendation to elaborate a 'Generic Containment' including all important components. On the one hand, this Generic Containment will help to rate analyses being performed with different lumped-parameter models. On the other hand, it can serve as a basis for testing new model developments on a commonly available and accepted basis. Within the SARNET2 Network of Excellence, such a Generic Containment nodalisation, based on a German PWR 1300 MWel, has been developed and is applied for a lumped parameter code-to-code comparison with increasing complexity. The initial benchmark step, 'Generic Containment-run-0', considered a strongly simplified SB LOCA transient in order to have a clear basis for the preparation of the inputs, their verification and to investigate the transferability of assumptions and specifications among different codes. Within the current step of the benchmark exercise, run-1, a more detailed evaluation is performed in order to achieve an understanding of the basic differences among the codes and models and the resulting deviations. This includes an identification and reduction of the user-dependent impact. This paper summarises the initial benchmark step run-0 and gives an outlook to the results of the current run-1, which is expected to be finished in mid 2012.

    M3 - Conference article in proceedings

    BT - ERMSAR 2012 Papers (CD)

    ER -

    Kelm S, Broxtermann P, Krajewski S, Allelein H-J, Preusser G, Sangiorgi M et al. A first step towards bringing (European) containment simulations to a common level. In ERMSAR 2012 Papers (CD). 2012