A study on the effect of flaw detection probability assumptions on risk reduction achieved by non-destructive inspection

Otso Cronvall (Corresponding Author), Kaisa Simola, Ilkka Männistö, J. Gunnars, L. Alverlind, P. Dillström, L. Gandossi

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    9 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Leakages and ruptures of piping components lead to reduction or loss of the pressure retaining capability of the system, and thus contribute to the overall risk associated with nuclear power plants. In-service inspection (ISI) aims at verifying that defects are not present in components of the pressure boundary or, if defects are present, ensuring that these are detected before they affect the safe operation of the plant. Reliability estimates of piping are needed e.g., in probabilistic safety assessment (PSA) studies, risk-informed ISI (RI-ISI) applications, and other structural reliability assessments. Probabilistic fracture mechanics models can account for ISI reliability, but a quantitative estimate for the latter is needed. This is normally expressed in terms of probability of detection (POD) curves, which correlate the probability of detecting a flaw with flaw size. A detailed POD curve is often difficult (or practically impossible) to obtain. If sufficient risk reduction can be shown by using simplified (but reasonably conservative) POD estimates, more complex PODs are not needed. This paper summarises the results of a study on the effect of piping inspection reliability assumptions on failure probability using structural reliability models. The main interest was to investigate whether it is justifiable to use a simplified POD curve. Further, the study compared various structural reliability calculation approaches for a set of analysis cases. The results indicate that the use of a simplified POD could be justifiable in RI-ISI applications.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)90-96
    Number of pages7
    JournalReliability Engineering and System Safety
    Volume105
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2012
    MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed
    EventEuropean Safety and Reliability Conference, ESREL 2010 - Rhodes, Greece
    Duration: 5 Sep 20109 Sep 2010

    Fingerprint

    Inspection
    Defects
    Fracture mechanics
    Risk assessment
    Nuclear power plants

    Keywords

    • Inspection reliability
    • probabilistic fracture mechanics (PFM)
    • probability of detection curves (POD)
    • risk-informed in-service inspection

    Cite this

    Cronvall, Otso ; Simola, Kaisa ; Männistö, Ilkka ; Gunnars, J. ; Alverlind, L. ; Dillström, P. ; Gandossi, L. / A study on the effect of flaw detection probability assumptions on risk reduction achieved by non-destructive inspection. In: Reliability Engineering and System Safety. 2012 ; Vol. 105. pp. 90-96.
    @article{cd9a1e3ec43b4c3c9af17895dc7a503a,
    title = "A study on the effect of flaw detection probability assumptions on risk reduction achieved by non-destructive inspection",
    abstract = "Leakages and ruptures of piping components lead to reduction or loss of the pressure retaining capability of the system, and thus contribute to the overall risk associated with nuclear power plants. In-service inspection (ISI) aims at verifying that defects are not present in components of the pressure boundary or, if defects are present, ensuring that these are detected before they affect the safe operation of the plant. Reliability estimates of piping are needed e.g., in probabilistic safety assessment (PSA) studies, risk-informed ISI (RI-ISI) applications, and other structural reliability assessments. Probabilistic fracture mechanics models can account for ISI reliability, but a quantitative estimate for the latter is needed. This is normally expressed in terms of probability of detection (POD) curves, which correlate the probability of detecting a flaw with flaw size. A detailed POD curve is often difficult (or practically impossible) to obtain. If sufficient risk reduction can be shown by using simplified (but reasonably conservative) POD estimates, more complex PODs are not needed. This paper summarises the results of a study on the effect of piping inspection reliability assumptions on failure probability using structural reliability models. The main interest was to investigate whether it is justifiable to use a simplified POD curve. Further, the study compared various structural reliability calculation approaches for a set of analysis cases. The results indicate that the use of a simplified POD could be justifiable in RI-ISI applications.",
    keywords = "Inspection reliability, probabilistic fracture mechanics (PFM), probability of detection curves (POD), risk-informed in-service inspection",
    author = "Otso Cronvall and Kaisa Simola and Ilkka M{\"a}nnist{\"o} and J. Gunnars and L. Alverlind and P. Dillstr{\"o}m and L. Gandossi",
    year = "2012",
    doi = "10.1016/j.ress.2012.03.012",
    language = "English",
    volume = "105",
    pages = "90--96",
    journal = "Reliability Engineering and System Safety",
    issn = "0951-8320",
    publisher = "Elsevier",

    }

    A study on the effect of flaw detection probability assumptions on risk reduction achieved by non-destructive inspection. / Cronvall, Otso (Corresponding Author); Simola, Kaisa; Männistö, Ilkka; Gunnars, J.; Alverlind, L.; Dillström, P.; Gandossi, L.

    In: Reliability Engineering and System Safety, Vol. 105, 2012, p. 90-96.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - A study on the effect of flaw detection probability assumptions on risk reduction achieved by non-destructive inspection

    AU - Cronvall, Otso

    AU - Simola, Kaisa

    AU - Männistö, Ilkka

    AU - Gunnars, J.

    AU - Alverlind, L.

    AU - Dillström, P.

    AU - Gandossi, L.

    PY - 2012

    Y1 - 2012

    N2 - Leakages and ruptures of piping components lead to reduction or loss of the pressure retaining capability of the system, and thus contribute to the overall risk associated with nuclear power plants. In-service inspection (ISI) aims at verifying that defects are not present in components of the pressure boundary or, if defects are present, ensuring that these are detected before they affect the safe operation of the plant. Reliability estimates of piping are needed e.g., in probabilistic safety assessment (PSA) studies, risk-informed ISI (RI-ISI) applications, and other structural reliability assessments. Probabilistic fracture mechanics models can account for ISI reliability, but a quantitative estimate for the latter is needed. This is normally expressed in terms of probability of detection (POD) curves, which correlate the probability of detecting a flaw with flaw size. A detailed POD curve is often difficult (or practically impossible) to obtain. If sufficient risk reduction can be shown by using simplified (but reasonably conservative) POD estimates, more complex PODs are not needed. This paper summarises the results of a study on the effect of piping inspection reliability assumptions on failure probability using structural reliability models. The main interest was to investigate whether it is justifiable to use a simplified POD curve. Further, the study compared various structural reliability calculation approaches for a set of analysis cases. The results indicate that the use of a simplified POD could be justifiable in RI-ISI applications.

    AB - Leakages and ruptures of piping components lead to reduction or loss of the pressure retaining capability of the system, and thus contribute to the overall risk associated with nuclear power plants. In-service inspection (ISI) aims at verifying that defects are not present in components of the pressure boundary or, if defects are present, ensuring that these are detected before they affect the safe operation of the plant. Reliability estimates of piping are needed e.g., in probabilistic safety assessment (PSA) studies, risk-informed ISI (RI-ISI) applications, and other structural reliability assessments. Probabilistic fracture mechanics models can account for ISI reliability, but a quantitative estimate for the latter is needed. This is normally expressed in terms of probability of detection (POD) curves, which correlate the probability of detecting a flaw with flaw size. A detailed POD curve is often difficult (or practically impossible) to obtain. If sufficient risk reduction can be shown by using simplified (but reasonably conservative) POD estimates, more complex PODs are not needed. This paper summarises the results of a study on the effect of piping inspection reliability assumptions on failure probability using structural reliability models. The main interest was to investigate whether it is justifiable to use a simplified POD curve. Further, the study compared various structural reliability calculation approaches for a set of analysis cases. The results indicate that the use of a simplified POD could be justifiable in RI-ISI applications.

    KW - Inspection reliability

    KW - probabilistic fracture mechanics (PFM)

    KW - probability of detection curves (POD)

    KW - risk-informed in-service inspection

    U2 - 10.1016/j.ress.2012.03.012

    DO - 10.1016/j.ress.2012.03.012

    M3 - Article

    VL - 105

    SP - 90

    EP - 96

    JO - Reliability Engineering and System Safety

    JF - Reliability Engineering and System Safety

    SN - 0951-8320

    ER -