Capturing deviations from design intent in building simulation models for risk assessment

Heikki Nikula, Seppo Sierla, Bryan O'Halloran, Tommi Karhela

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Simulation-based methods are emerging to address the challenges of complex systems risk assessment, and this paper identifies two problems related to the use of such methods. First, the methods cannot identify new hazards if the simulation model builders are expected to foresee the hazards and incorporate the abnormal behavior related to the hazard into the simulation model. Therefore, this paper uses the concept of deviation from design intent to systematically capture abnormal conditions that may lead to component failures, hazards, or both. Second, simulation-based risk assessment methods should explicitly consider what expertise is required from the experts that build and use the simulation models - the transfer of the methods to real engineering practice will be severely hindered if they must be performed by persons that are expert in domain safety as well as advanced computer simulation-based methods. This paper addresses both problems in the context of the functional failure identification and propagation (FFIP) method. One industrially established risk assessment method, hazard and operability study (HAZOP), is harnessed to systematically obtain the deviations from design intent in the application under study. An information system presents a user interface that is understandable to HAZOP professionals, so that their inputs are transparently entered to a data model that captures the deviations. From the data model, instructions for configuring FFIP simulation models are printed in a form that is understandable for FFIP experts. The method is demonstrated for discovering a hazard resulting from system-wide fault propagation in a boiling water reactor case.
Original languageEnglish
Article number041011
JournalJournal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering
Volume15
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015
MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

Fingerprint

Risk assessment
Hazards
Data structures
Boiling water reactors
User interfaces
Large scale systems
Information systems
Computer simulation

Cite this

Nikula, Heikki ; Sierla, Seppo ; O'Halloran, Bryan ; Karhela, Tommi. / Capturing deviations from design intent in building simulation models for risk assessment. In: Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering. 2015 ; Vol. 15, No. 4.
@article{d46c01c002b546db8a7d076aa22879da,
title = "Capturing deviations from design intent in building simulation models for risk assessment",
abstract = "Simulation-based methods are emerging to address the challenges of complex systems risk assessment, and this paper identifies two problems related to the use of such methods. First, the methods cannot identify new hazards if the simulation model builders are expected to foresee the hazards and incorporate the abnormal behavior related to the hazard into the simulation model. Therefore, this paper uses the concept of deviation from design intent to systematically capture abnormal conditions that may lead to component failures, hazards, or both. Second, simulation-based risk assessment methods should explicitly consider what expertise is required from the experts that build and use the simulation models - the transfer of the methods to real engineering practice will be severely hindered if they must be performed by persons that are expert in domain safety as well as advanced computer simulation-based methods. This paper addresses both problems in the context of the functional failure identification and propagation (FFIP) method. One industrially established risk assessment method, hazard and operability study (HAZOP), is harnessed to systematically obtain the deviations from design intent in the application under study. An information system presents a user interface that is understandable to HAZOP professionals, so that their inputs are transparently entered to a data model that captures the deviations. From the data model, instructions for configuring FFIP simulation models are printed in a form that is understandable for FFIP experts. The method is demonstrated for discovering a hazard resulting from system-wide fault propagation in a boiling water reactor case.",
author = "Heikki Nikula and Seppo Sierla and Bryan O'Halloran and Tommi Karhela",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1115/1.4030385",
language = "English",
volume = "15",
journal = "Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering",
issn = "1530-9827",
publisher = "American Society of Mechanical Engineers ASME",
number = "4",

}

Capturing deviations from design intent in building simulation models for risk assessment. / Nikula, Heikki; Sierla, Seppo; O'Halloran, Bryan; Karhela, Tommi.

In: Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering, Vol. 15, No. 4, 041011, 2015.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Capturing deviations from design intent in building simulation models for risk assessment

AU - Nikula, Heikki

AU - Sierla, Seppo

AU - O'Halloran, Bryan

AU - Karhela, Tommi

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Simulation-based methods are emerging to address the challenges of complex systems risk assessment, and this paper identifies two problems related to the use of such methods. First, the methods cannot identify new hazards if the simulation model builders are expected to foresee the hazards and incorporate the abnormal behavior related to the hazard into the simulation model. Therefore, this paper uses the concept of deviation from design intent to systematically capture abnormal conditions that may lead to component failures, hazards, or both. Second, simulation-based risk assessment methods should explicitly consider what expertise is required from the experts that build and use the simulation models - the transfer of the methods to real engineering practice will be severely hindered if they must be performed by persons that are expert in domain safety as well as advanced computer simulation-based methods. This paper addresses both problems in the context of the functional failure identification and propagation (FFIP) method. One industrially established risk assessment method, hazard and operability study (HAZOP), is harnessed to systematically obtain the deviations from design intent in the application under study. An information system presents a user interface that is understandable to HAZOP professionals, so that their inputs are transparently entered to a data model that captures the deviations. From the data model, instructions for configuring FFIP simulation models are printed in a form that is understandable for FFIP experts. The method is demonstrated for discovering a hazard resulting from system-wide fault propagation in a boiling water reactor case.

AB - Simulation-based methods are emerging to address the challenges of complex systems risk assessment, and this paper identifies two problems related to the use of such methods. First, the methods cannot identify new hazards if the simulation model builders are expected to foresee the hazards and incorporate the abnormal behavior related to the hazard into the simulation model. Therefore, this paper uses the concept of deviation from design intent to systematically capture abnormal conditions that may lead to component failures, hazards, or both. Second, simulation-based risk assessment methods should explicitly consider what expertise is required from the experts that build and use the simulation models - the transfer of the methods to real engineering practice will be severely hindered if they must be performed by persons that are expert in domain safety as well as advanced computer simulation-based methods. This paper addresses both problems in the context of the functional failure identification and propagation (FFIP) method. One industrially established risk assessment method, hazard and operability study (HAZOP), is harnessed to systematically obtain the deviations from design intent in the application under study. An information system presents a user interface that is understandable to HAZOP professionals, so that their inputs are transparently entered to a data model that captures the deviations. From the data model, instructions for configuring FFIP simulation models are printed in a form that is understandable for FFIP experts. The method is demonstrated for discovering a hazard resulting from system-wide fault propagation in a boiling water reactor case.

U2 - 10.1115/1.4030385

DO - 10.1115/1.4030385

M3 - Article

VL - 15

JO - Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering

JF - Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering

SN - 1530-9827

IS - 4

M1 - 041011

ER -