Clearing of roads to Hästholmen after a storm: a case study in emergency operations modelling

Research output: Book/ReportReport

Abstract

Securing logistical connections to a nuclear power plant, especially in exceptional circumstances, is an important part of nuclear safety. This report considers the schedule risk of clearing a road transport route to the Hästholmen nuclear power plant site after a storm as cut down trees that block some essential roads. The local road network is described. A coarse inventory is made of the trees that might block traffic on a road in this network if they fell on it in a suitable angle. The work process of a fireman crew clearing the road is presented, and an activity network model of the process is formulated. A Monte Carlo simulation model of the network, with probabilistic distributions for the durations of individual activities, is implemented in Microsoft Excel and analysed. The model describes one scenario, where a west storm has fallen down trees. To illustrate the use of an emergency operations model in decision support, two alternative courses of action are modelled and analysed: one in which a single fire crew clears Atomitie, and another where the fire foreman, after situation assessment, calls another crew to clear Lappomjärventie which constitutes a parallel route to Hästholmen for much of Atomitie's length. The model class, activity networks, and the analysis method, Monte Carlo simulation, are useful in analysing schedule risks of operations. However, a comprehensive analysis requires the analysis of more weather scenarios, a more detailed analysis and representation of various alternatives of the clearing process, more attention to the probability that a wind of certain speed can fall down a given tree, and other considerations.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherVTT Technical Research Centre of Finland
Number of pages28
Publication statusPublished - 2014
MoE publication typeD4 Published development or research report or study

Publication series

SeriesVTT Research Report
NumberVTT-R-05654-14

Fingerprint

Nuclear power plants
Fires
Supervisory personnel
Monte Carlo simulation

Keywords

  • prevention and emergency operations
  • mathematical modelling
  • nuclear safety
  • probabilistic risk analysis

Cite this

Karanta, I. (2014). Clearing of roads to Hästholmen after a storm: a case study in emergency operations modelling. VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland. VTT Research Report, No. VTT-R-05654-14
Karanta, Ilkka. / Clearing of roads to Hästholmen after a storm : a case study in emergency operations modelling. VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2014. 28 p. (VTT Research Report; No. VTT-R-05654-14).
@book{16861905dfc44293a0baf4731f0481ef,
title = "Clearing of roads to H{\"a}stholmen after a storm: a case study in emergency operations modelling",
abstract = "Securing logistical connections to a nuclear power plant, especially in exceptional circumstances, is an important part of nuclear safety. This report considers the schedule risk of clearing a road transport route to the H{\"a}stholmen nuclear power plant site after a storm as cut down trees that block some essential roads. The local road network is described. A coarse inventory is made of the trees that might block traffic on a road in this network if they fell on it in a suitable angle. The work process of a fireman crew clearing the road is presented, and an activity network model of the process is formulated. A Monte Carlo simulation model of the network, with probabilistic distributions for the durations of individual activities, is implemented in Microsoft Excel and analysed. The model describes one scenario, where a west storm has fallen down trees. To illustrate the use of an emergency operations model in decision support, two alternative courses of action are modelled and analysed: one in which a single fire crew clears Atomitie, and another where the fire foreman, after situation assessment, calls another crew to clear Lappomj{\"a}rventie which constitutes a parallel route to H{\"a}stholmen for much of Atomitie's length. The model class, activity networks, and the analysis method, Monte Carlo simulation, are useful in analysing schedule risks of operations. However, a comprehensive analysis requires the analysis of more weather scenarios, a more detailed analysis and representation of various alternatives of the clearing process, more attention to the probability that a wind of certain speed can fall down a given tree, and other considerations.",
keywords = "prevention and emergency operations, mathematical modelling, nuclear safety, probabilistic risk analysis",
author = "Ilkka Karanta",
note = "Project code: 85364",
year = "2014",
language = "English",
series = "VTT Research Report",
publisher = "VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland",
number = "VTT-R-05654-14",
address = "Finland",

}

Karanta, I 2014, Clearing of roads to Hästholmen after a storm: a case study in emergency operations modelling. VTT Research Report, no. VTT-R-05654-14, VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland.

Clearing of roads to Hästholmen after a storm : a case study in emergency operations modelling. / Karanta, Ilkka.

VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2014. 28 p. (VTT Research Report; No. VTT-R-05654-14).

Research output: Book/ReportReport

TY - BOOK

T1 - Clearing of roads to Hästholmen after a storm

T2 - a case study in emergency operations modelling

AU - Karanta, Ilkka

N1 - Project code: 85364

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - Securing logistical connections to a nuclear power plant, especially in exceptional circumstances, is an important part of nuclear safety. This report considers the schedule risk of clearing a road transport route to the Hästholmen nuclear power plant site after a storm as cut down trees that block some essential roads. The local road network is described. A coarse inventory is made of the trees that might block traffic on a road in this network if they fell on it in a suitable angle. The work process of a fireman crew clearing the road is presented, and an activity network model of the process is formulated. A Monte Carlo simulation model of the network, with probabilistic distributions for the durations of individual activities, is implemented in Microsoft Excel and analysed. The model describes one scenario, where a west storm has fallen down trees. To illustrate the use of an emergency operations model in decision support, two alternative courses of action are modelled and analysed: one in which a single fire crew clears Atomitie, and another where the fire foreman, after situation assessment, calls another crew to clear Lappomjärventie which constitutes a parallel route to Hästholmen for much of Atomitie's length. The model class, activity networks, and the analysis method, Monte Carlo simulation, are useful in analysing schedule risks of operations. However, a comprehensive analysis requires the analysis of more weather scenarios, a more detailed analysis and representation of various alternatives of the clearing process, more attention to the probability that a wind of certain speed can fall down a given tree, and other considerations.

AB - Securing logistical connections to a nuclear power plant, especially in exceptional circumstances, is an important part of nuclear safety. This report considers the schedule risk of clearing a road transport route to the Hästholmen nuclear power plant site after a storm as cut down trees that block some essential roads. The local road network is described. A coarse inventory is made of the trees that might block traffic on a road in this network if they fell on it in a suitable angle. The work process of a fireman crew clearing the road is presented, and an activity network model of the process is formulated. A Monte Carlo simulation model of the network, with probabilistic distributions for the durations of individual activities, is implemented in Microsoft Excel and analysed. The model describes one scenario, where a west storm has fallen down trees. To illustrate the use of an emergency operations model in decision support, two alternative courses of action are modelled and analysed: one in which a single fire crew clears Atomitie, and another where the fire foreman, after situation assessment, calls another crew to clear Lappomjärventie which constitutes a parallel route to Hästholmen for much of Atomitie's length. The model class, activity networks, and the analysis method, Monte Carlo simulation, are useful in analysing schedule risks of operations. However, a comprehensive analysis requires the analysis of more weather scenarios, a more detailed analysis and representation of various alternatives of the clearing process, more attention to the probability that a wind of certain speed can fall down a given tree, and other considerations.

KW - prevention and emergency operations

KW - mathematical modelling

KW - nuclear safety

KW - probabilistic risk analysis

M3 - Report

T3 - VTT Research Report

BT - Clearing of roads to Hästholmen after a storm

PB - VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland

ER -

Karanta I. Clearing of roads to Hästholmen after a storm: a case study in emergency operations modelling. VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2014. 28 p. (VTT Research Report; No. VTT-R-05654-14).