Determination of tolerance limits for fuel assembly fission gas release summary statistics

Henri Loukusa (Corresponding Author), Ville Tulkki

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    Abstract

    Instant release fraction is used in spent fuel final disposal studies to estimate the quickly released inventory from a spent fuel final disposal capsule. The instant release fraction has been correlated with fission gas release, which can be readily calculated with fuel performance codes. In spent fuel final disposal, individual rod fission gas releases are not important, as the fuel is treated in complete capsules containing multiple assemblies. Therefore assembly summary statistics are more suitable for this purpose. Summary statistics such as mean or maximum are useful in this application. However, the nominal values for the assembly mean fission gas release may be non conservative estimates, whereas the assembly maximum fission gas release is a highly conservative assumption. This results from the “cutoff log-normal” distribution of fission gas release in an assembly and in a more general level, the reactor core. The tail of the distribution contains a small amount of rods with a high fission gas release, whereas a large number of rods typically have low fission gas releases.
    Compared to nominal summary statistics, a better method to show compliance with regulatory criteria is to determine the distribution of the assembly mean, taking into account the effects of manufacturing tolerances and uncertainty of the power history. The upper tolerance limit is straightforward to calculate with order statistics and with suitable parameters it is accepted by many regulatory authorities. In this work, the calculation of tolerance limits has been applied to mean fission gas release in complete fuel assemblies. A calculation system for such analyses has been developed at VTT, and by calculating each rod multiple times it can be used to determine the tolerance limits for complete nuclear reactor cores. In statistical analyses, typically a large number of simulations must be run. This increases the probability of failure of the simulation program due to non convergence of the calculation. This results in missing data, and this could prevent the use of order statistics which are based on the sorting of observations. With missing data, the real order of the observations is unknown. This work suggests a suitable data treatment method to overcome this problem.
    Original languageEnglish
    Article number110438
    JournalNuclear Engineering and Design
    Volume358
    Early online date21 Nov 2019
    DOIs
    Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 21 Nov 2019
    MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

    Fingerprint

    fission
    assembly
    tolerance
    Gases
    Statistics
    statistics
    gases
    gas
    spent fuels
    Spent fuels
    disposal
    rods
    reactor cores
    Reactor cores
    capsules
    assemblies
    Capsules
    nuclear reactors
    Normal distribution
    estimates

    Cite this

    @article{39f93e436e634e3bb4aa2fbb7b3274cd,
    title = "Determination of tolerance limits for fuel assembly fission gas release summary statistics",
    abstract = "Instant release fraction is used in spent fuel final disposal studies to estimate the quickly released inventory from a spent fuel final disposal capsule. The instant release fraction has been correlated with fission gas release, which can be readily calculated with fuel performance codes. In spent fuel final disposal, individual rod fission gas releases are not important, as the fuel is treated in complete capsules containing multiple assemblies. Therefore assembly summary statistics are more suitable for this purpose. Summary statistics such as mean or maximum are useful in this application. However, the nominal values for the assembly mean fission gas release may be non conservative estimates, whereas the assembly maximum fission gas release is a highly conservative assumption. This results from the “cutoff log-normal” distribution of fission gas release in an assembly and in a more general level, the reactor core. The tail of the distribution contains a small amount of rods with a high fission gas release, whereas a large number of rods typically have low fission gas releases.Compared to nominal summary statistics, a better method to show compliance with regulatory criteria is to determine the distribution of the assembly mean, taking into account the effects of manufacturing tolerances and uncertainty of the power history. The upper tolerance limit is straightforward to calculate with order statistics and with suitable parameters it is accepted by many regulatory authorities. In this work, the calculation of tolerance limits has been applied to mean fission gas release in complete fuel assemblies. A calculation system for such analyses has been developed at VTT, and by calculating each rod multiple times it can be used to determine the tolerance limits for complete nuclear reactor cores. In statistical analyses, typically a large number of simulations must be run. This increases the probability of failure of the simulation program due to non convergence of the calculation. This results in missing data, and this could prevent the use of order statistics which are based on the sorting of observations. With missing data, the real order of the observations is unknown. This work suggests a suitable data treatment method to overcome this problem.",
    author = "Henri Loukusa and Ville Tulkki",
    year = "2019",
    month = "11",
    day = "21",
    doi = "10.1016/j.nucengdes.2019.110438",
    language = "English",
    volume = "358",
    journal = "Nuclear Engineering and Design",
    issn = "0029-5493",
    publisher = "Elsevier",

    }

    Determination of tolerance limits for fuel assembly fission gas release summary statistics. / Loukusa, Henri (Corresponding Author); Tulkki, Ville.

    In: Nuclear Engineering and Design, Vol. 358, 110438, 03.2020.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Determination of tolerance limits for fuel assembly fission gas release summary statistics

    AU - Loukusa, Henri

    AU - Tulkki, Ville

    PY - 2019/11/21

    Y1 - 2019/11/21

    N2 - Instant release fraction is used in spent fuel final disposal studies to estimate the quickly released inventory from a spent fuel final disposal capsule. The instant release fraction has been correlated with fission gas release, which can be readily calculated with fuel performance codes. In spent fuel final disposal, individual rod fission gas releases are not important, as the fuel is treated in complete capsules containing multiple assemblies. Therefore assembly summary statistics are more suitable for this purpose. Summary statistics such as mean or maximum are useful in this application. However, the nominal values for the assembly mean fission gas release may be non conservative estimates, whereas the assembly maximum fission gas release is a highly conservative assumption. This results from the “cutoff log-normal” distribution of fission gas release in an assembly and in a more general level, the reactor core. The tail of the distribution contains a small amount of rods with a high fission gas release, whereas a large number of rods typically have low fission gas releases.Compared to nominal summary statistics, a better method to show compliance with regulatory criteria is to determine the distribution of the assembly mean, taking into account the effects of manufacturing tolerances and uncertainty of the power history. The upper tolerance limit is straightforward to calculate with order statistics and with suitable parameters it is accepted by many regulatory authorities. In this work, the calculation of tolerance limits has been applied to mean fission gas release in complete fuel assemblies. A calculation system for such analyses has been developed at VTT, and by calculating each rod multiple times it can be used to determine the tolerance limits for complete nuclear reactor cores. In statistical analyses, typically a large number of simulations must be run. This increases the probability of failure of the simulation program due to non convergence of the calculation. This results in missing data, and this could prevent the use of order statistics which are based on the sorting of observations. With missing data, the real order of the observations is unknown. This work suggests a suitable data treatment method to overcome this problem.

    AB - Instant release fraction is used in spent fuel final disposal studies to estimate the quickly released inventory from a spent fuel final disposal capsule. The instant release fraction has been correlated with fission gas release, which can be readily calculated with fuel performance codes. In spent fuel final disposal, individual rod fission gas releases are not important, as the fuel is treated in complete capsules containing multiple assemblies. Therefore assembly summary statistics are more suitable for this purpose. Summary statistics such as mean or maximum are useful in this application. However, the nominal values for the assembly mean fission gas release may be non conservative estimates, whereas the assembly maximum fission gas release is a highly conservative assumption. This results from the “cutoff log-normal” distribution of fission gas release in an assembly and in a more general level, the reactor core. The tail of the distribution contains a small amount of rods with a high fission gas release, whereas a large number of rods typically have low fission gas releases.Compared to nominal summary statistics, a better method to show compliance with regulatory criteria is to determine the distribution of the assembly mean, taking into account the effects of manufacturing tolerances and uncertainty of the power history. The upper tolerance limit is straightforward to calculate with order statistics and with suitable parameters it is accepted by many regulatory authorities. In this work, the calculation of tolerance limits has been applied to mean fission gas release in complete fuel assemblies. A calculation system for such analyses has been developed at VTT, and by calculating each rod multiple times it can be used to determine the tolerance limits for complete nuclear reactor cores. In statistical analyses, typically a large number of simulations must be run. This increases the probability of failure of the simulation program due to non convergence of the calculation. This results in missing data, and this could prevent the use of order statistics which are based on the sorting of observations. With missing data, the real order of the observations is unknown. This work suggests a suitable data treatment method to overcome this problem.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85075203289&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.nucengdes.2019.110438

    DO - 10.1016/j.nucengdes.2019.110438

    M3 - Article

    VL - 358

    JO - Nuclear Engineering and Design

    JF - Nuclear Engineering and Design

    SN - 0029-5493

    M1 - 110438

    ER -