Drinking water treatment residual use in urban soils: Balancing metal immobilization and phosphorus availability

Daryl Yi Yuan Tay, Ryosuke Fujinuma, Laura A. Wendling

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Pollution in urban environments has raised concerns about the consumer safety of food produced by urban horticulture. Could a solid by-product of drinking water treatment provide the answer? Soil amendment with drinking water treatment residuals (DWTRs) has been shown to limit the uptake of metal contaminants, effectively immobilizing these elements within the soil; however, DWTRs possess a strong specific affinity for P and soil amendment with DWTRs can reduce P availability, thereby inducing plant P deficiencies and restricting growth. We conducted a glasshouse pot experiment to investigate the effect of alum-based DWTR amendment rate and P fertilizer placement method on Brassica pekinensis growth and As, Cd and P uptake under controlled conditions. Amendment of sandy loam soil A with 2–4 wt% DWTRs significantly (p < 0.001) reduced the Cd content of B. pekinensis tissues relative to untreated controls, with no significant difference in the P content of B. pekinensis tissues. Across all DWTR application rates examined (2–6 wt%), banded P fertilizer application resulted in 30–47% greater aboveground tissue P concentration compared to broadcast P fertilizer treatments (p < 0.05). Both the As and Cd content of B. pekinensis tissues were significantly (p < 0.001) reduced following 2–6 wt% amendment of sandy loam B with DWTRs. Results showed that a DWTR amendment rate of 2 wt% coupled with banded P fertilizer application resulted in the greatest B. pekinensis aboveground tissue biomass, along with a reduction in plant tissue Cd or As concentrations not significantly different from higher rates of DWTR amendment. Tissue P concentrations of B. pekinensis grown in soils amended with 2 wt% DWTRs were adequate for uninhibited plant growth. The use of DWTRs as an amendment to urban horticultural soils may provide a low-cost means of immobilizing trace metals without limiting plant uptake of applied fertilizer P. Additional study is required to quantify trace element release from DWTR-amended soils as a function of soil oxidation-reduction status.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)113-121
Number of pages9
JournalGeoderma
Volume305
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2017
MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

Fingerprint

urban soils
water treatment
immobilization
drinking water
metals
Brassica rapa subsp. pekinensis
phosphorus
metal
soil
fertilizer application
soil amendment
fertilizer
soil amendments
sandy loam
uptake mechanisms
drinking water treatment
trace elements
urban horticulture
horticultural soils
fertilizers

Keywords

  • brownfield
  • metal availability
  • Phosphorus
  • soil remediation
  • urban soil

Cite this

@article{a569f89c7dc04cbab49772588d0bcf31,
title = "Drinking water treatment residual use in urban soils: Balancing metal immobilization and phosphorus availability",
abstract = "Pollution in urban environments has raised concerns about the consumer safety of food produced by urban horticulture. Could a solid by-product of drinking water treatment provide the answer? Soil amendment with drinking water treatment residuals (DWTRs) has been shown to limit the uptake of metal contaminants, effectively immobilizing these elements within the soil; however, DWTRs possess a strong specific affinity for P and soil amendment with DWTRs can reduce P availability, thereby inducing plant P deficiencies and restricting growth. We conducted a glasshouse pot experiment to investigate the effect of alum-based DWTR amendment rate and P fertilizer placement method on Brassica pekinensis growth and As, Cd and P uptake under controlled conditions. Amendment of sandy loam soil A with 2–4 wt{\%} DWTRs significantly (p < 0.001) reduced the Cd content of B. pekinensis tissues relative to untreated controls, with no significant difference in the P content of B. pekinensis tissues. Across all DWTR application rates examined (2–6 wt{\%}), banded P fertilizer application resulted in 30–47{\%} greater aboveground tissue P concentration compared to broadcast P fertilizer treatments (p < 0.05). Both the As and Cd content of B. pekinensis tissues were significantly (p < 0.001) reduced following 2–6 wt{\%} amendment of sandy loam B with DWTRs. Results showed that a DWTR amendment rate of 2 wt{\%} coupled with banded P fertilizer application resulted in the greatest B. pekinensis aboveground tissue biomass, along with a reduction in plant tissue Cd or As concentrations not significantly different from higher rates of DWTR amendment. Tissue P concentrations of B. pekinensis grown in soils amended with 2 wt{\%} DWTRs were adequate for uninhibited plant growth. The use of DWTRs as an amendment to urban horticultural soils may provide a low-cost means of immobilizing trace metals without limiting plant uptake of applied fertilizer P. Additional study is required to quantify trace element release from DWTR-amended soils as a function of soil oxidation-reduction status.",
keywords = "brownfield, metal availability, Phosphorus, soil remediation, urban soil",
author = "Tay, {Daryl Yi Yuan} and Ryosuke Fujinuma and Wendling, {Laura A.}",
year = "2017",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.05.047",
language = "English",
volume = "305",
pages = "113--121",
journal = "Geoderma",
issn = "0016-7061",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Drinking water treatment residual use in urban soils: Balancing metal immobilization and phosphorus availability. / Tay, Daryl Yi Yuan; Fujinuma, Ryosuke; Wendling, Laura A.

In: Geoderma, Vol. 305, 01.11.2017, p. 113-121.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Drinking water treatment residual use in urban soils: Balancing metal immobilization and phosphorus availability

AU - Tay, Daryl Yi Yuan

AU - Fujinuma, Ryosuke

AU - Wendling, Laura A.

PY - 2017/11/1

Y1 - 2017/11/1

N2 - Pollution in urban environments has raised concerns about the consumer safety of food produced by urban horticulture. Could a solid by-product of drinking water treatment provide the answer? Soil amendment with drinking water treatment residuals (DWTRs) has been shown to limit the uptake of metal contaminants, effectively immobilizing these elements within the soil; however, DWTRs possess a strong specific affinity for P and soil amendment with DWTRs can reduce P availability, thereby inducing plant P deficiencies and restricting growth. We conducted a glasshouse pot experiment to investigate the effect of alum-based DWTR amendment rate and P fertilizer placement method on Brassica pekinensis growth and As, Cd and P uptake under controlled conditions. Amendment of sandy loam soil A with 2–4 wt% DWTRs significantly (p < 0.001) reduced the Cd content of B. pekinensis tissues relative to untreated controls, with no significant difference in the P content of B. pekinensis tissues. Across all DWTR application rates examined (2–6 wt%), banded P fertilizer application resulted in 30–47% greater aboveground tissue P concentration compared to broadcast P fertilizer treatments (p < 0.05). Both the As and Cd content of B. pekinensis tissues were significantly (p < 0.001) reduced following 2–6 wt% amendment of sandy loam B with DWTRs. Results showed that a DWTR amendment rate of 2 wt% coupled with banded P fertilizer application resulted in the greatest B. pekinensis aboveground tissue biomass, along with a reduction in plant tissue Cd or As concentrations not significantly different from higher rates of DWTR amendment. Tissue P concentrations of B. pekinensis grown in soils amended with 2 wt% DWTRs were adequate for uninhibited plant growth. The use of DWTRs as an amendment to urban horticultural soils may provide a low-cost means of immobilizing trace metals without limiting plant uptake of applied fertilizer P. Additional study is required to quantify trace element release from DWTR-amended soils as a function of soil oxidation-reduction status.

AB - Pollution in urban environments has raised concerns about the consumer safety of food produced by urban horticulture. Could a solid by-product of drinking water treatment provide the answer? Soil amendment with drinking water treatment residuals (DWTRs) has been shown to limit the uptake of metal contaminants, effectively immobilizing these elements within the soil; however, DWTRs possess a strong specific affinity for P and soil amendment with DWTRs can reduce P availability, thereby inducing plant P deficiencies and restricting growth. We conducted a glasshouse pot experiment to investigate the effect of alum-based DWTR amendment rate and P fertilizer placement method on Brassica pekinensis growth and As, Cd and P uptake under controlled conditions. Amendment of sandy loam soil A with 2–4 wt% DWTRs significantly (p < 0.001) reduced the Cd content of B. pekinensis tissues relative to untreated controls, with no significant difference in the P content of B. pekinensis tissues. Across all DWTR application rates examined (2–6 wt%), banded P fertilizer application resulted in 30–47% greater aboveground tissue P concentration compared to broadcast P fertilizer treatments (p < 0.05). Both the As and Cd content of B. pekinensis tissues were significantly (p < 0.001) reduced following 2–6 wt% amendment of sandy loam B with DWTRs. Results showed that a DWTR amendment rate of 2 wt% coupled with banded P fertilizer application resulted in the greatest B. pekinensis aboveground tissue biomass, along with a reduction in plant tissue Cd or As concentrations not significantly different from higher rates of DWTR amendment. Tissue P concentrations of B. pekinensis grown in soils amended with 2 wt% DWTRs were adequate for uninhibited plant growth. The use of DWTRs as an amendment to urban horticultural soils may provide a low-cost means of immobilizing trace metals without limiting plant uptake of applied fertilizer P. Additional study is required to quantify trace element release from DWTR-amended soils as a function of soil oxidation-reduction status.

KW - brownfield

KW - metal availability

KW - Phosphorus

KW - soil remediation

KW - urban soil

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85020317431&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.05.047

DO - 10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.05.047

M3 - Article

VL - 305

SP - 113

EP - 121

JO - Geoderma

JF - Geoderma

SN - 0016-7061

ER -