Drivers’ response to speed warnings provided by a smart phone app

Nicola J. Starkey (Corresponding Author), Samuel G. Charlton, Neha Malhotra, Esko Lehtonen

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    Abstract

    The distractive effects of mobile phones are well documented, but the recent development of mobile phone apps that provide speed advisory warnings raises the possibility that this technology may be used to improve driver safety in older vehicles. We examined the effects of an intelligent speed advisory (ISA) app on driving performance in a simulator. One hundred and four participants (mean age = 35.52 years; 52 male) were allocated to complete the drive with the ISA app in one of five modes: active audio visual (n = 22), active visual (n = 22), passive audio visual (n = 21), passive visual (n = 21) or control (n = 18). Another 19 participants (mean age = 27.53 years; 8 male) completed the study wearing eye-tracking glasses. Participants drove a simulated 26.4 km section of rural road which incorporated typical hazards and three speed compliance zones (100 km/h, 80 km/h and 60 km/h speed limits). The app led to good compliance with the posted speed limits, particularly during the 60 km/h road segment, where the control group drove at significantly higher speeds than the groups with the ISA app. No significant differences between the four versions of the ISA app were observed, either for speed compliance or the number of speeding alerts received. Across the entire simulated drive there were relatively few glances at the app with an average glance duration of 190 ms. The ISA app did not lead to any negative effects on driving performance; lane keeping was maintained and it did not impede participants’ ability to overtake vehicles. These findings suggest that when properly configured ISA apps have a demonstrable safety benefit and do not produce adverse distractive effects. The greatest challenge may be encouraging drivers’ to use them appropriately and consistently.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)209-221
    Number of pages13
    JournalTransportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies
    Volume110
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Jan 2020
    MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

    Fingerprint

    Application programs
    driver
    speed limit
    Mobile phones
    road
    Rural roads
    performance
    Group
    Hazards
    Simulators
    ability
    Glass

    Keywords

    • App
    • Distraction
    • Driver behaviour
    • Intelligent speed advisory
    • Speed
    • Technology

    Cite this

    Starkey, Nicola J. ; Charlton, Samuel G. ; Malhotra, Neha ; Lehtonen, Esko. / Drivers’ response to speed warnings provided by a smart phone app. In: Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies. 2020 ; Vol. 110. pp. 209-221.
    @article{41301777c51b466f9cb622a4842d07e1,
    title = "Drivers’ response to speed warnings provided by a smart phone app",
    abstract = "The distractive effects of mobile phones are well documented, but the recent development of mobile phone apps that provide speed advisory warnings raises the possibility that this technology may be used to improve driver safety in older vehicles. We examined the effects of an intelligent speed advisory (ISA) app on driving performance in a simulator. One hundred and four participants (mean age = 35.52 years; 52 male) were allocated to complete the drive with the ISA app in one of five modes: active audio visual (n = 22), active visual (n = 22), passive audio visual (n = 21), passive visual (n = 21) or control (n = 18). Another 19 participants (mean age = 27.53 years; 8 male) completed the study wearing eye-tracking glasses. Participants drove a simulated 26.4 km section of rural road which incorporated typical hazards and three speed compliance zones (100 km/h, 80 km/h and 60 km/h speed limits). The app led to good compliance with the posted speed limits, particularly during the 60 km/h road segment, where the control group drove at significantly higher speeds than the groups with the ISA app. No significant differences between the four versions of the ISA app were observed, either for speed compliance or the number of speeding alerts received. Across the entire simulated drive there were relatively few glances at the app with an average glance duration of 190 ms. The ISA app did not lead to any negative effects on driving performance; lane keeping was maintained and it did not impede participants’ ability to overtake vehicles. These findings suggest that when properly configured ISA apps have a demonstrable safety benefit and do not produce adverse distractive effects. The greatest challenge may be encouraging drivers’ to use them appropriately and consistently.",
    keywords = "App, Distraction, Driver behaviour, Intelligent speed advisory, Speed, Technology",
    author = "Starkey, {Nicola J.} and Charlton, {Samuel G.} and Neha Malhotra and Esko Lehtonen",
    year = "2020",
    month = "1",
    doi = "10.1016/j.trc.2019.11.020",
    language = "English",
    volume = "110",
    pages = "209--221",
    journal = "Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies",
    issn = "0968-090X",
    publisher = "Elsevier",

    }

    Drivers’ response to speed warnings provided by a smart phone app. / Starkey, Nicola J. (Corresponding Author); Charlton, Samuel G.; Malhotra, Neha; Lehtonen, Esko.

    In: Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, Vol. 110, 01.2020, p. 209-221.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Drivers’ response to speed warnings provided by a smart phone app

    AU - Starkey, Nicola J.

    AU - Charlton, Samuel G.

    AU - Malhotra, Neha

    AU - Lehtonen, Esko

    PY - 2020/1

    Y1 - 2020/1

    N2 - The distractive effects of mobile phones are well documented, but the recent development of mobile phone apps that provide speed advisory warnings raises the possibility that this technology may be used to improve driver safety in older vehicles. We examined the effects of an intelligent speed advisory (ISA) app on driving performance in a simulator. One hundred and four participants (mean age = 35.52 years; 52 male) were allocated to complete the drive with the ISA app in one of five modes: active audio visual (n = 22), active visual (n = 22), passive audio visual (n = 21), passive visual (n = 21) or control (n = 18). Another 19 participants (mean age = 27.53 years; 8 male) completed the study wearing eye-tracking glasses. Participants drove a simulated 26.4 km section of rural road which incorporated typical hazards and three speed compliance zones (100 km/h, 80 km/h and 60 km/h speed limits). The app led to good compliance with the posted speed limits, particularly during the 60 km/h road segment, where the control group drove at significantly higher speeds than the groups with the ISA app. No significant differences between the four versions of the ISA app were observed, either for speed compliance or the number of speeding alerts received. Across the entire simulated drive there were relatively few glances at the app with an average glance duration of 190 ms. The ISA app did not lead to any negative effects on driving performance; lane keeping was maintained and it did not impede participants’ ability to overtake vehicles. These findings suggest that when properly configured ISA apps have a demonstrable safety benefit and do not produce adverse distractive effects. The greatest challenge may be encouraging drivers’ to use them appropriately and consistently.

    AB - The distractive effects of mobile phones are well documented, but the recent development of mobile phone apps that provide speed advisory warnings raises the possibility that this technology may be used to improve driver safety in older vehicles. We examined the effects of an intelligent speed advisory (ISA) app on driving performance in a simulator. One hundred and four participants (mean age = 35.52 years; 52 male) were allocated to complete the drive with the ISA app in one of five modes: active audio visual (n = 22), active visual (n = 22), passive audio visual (n = 21), passive visual (n = 21) or control (n = 18). Another 19 participants (mean age = 27.53 years; 8 male) completed the study wearing eye-tracking glasses. Participants drove a simulated 26.4 km section of rural road which incorporated typical hazards and three speed compliance zones (100 km/h, 80 km/h and 60 km/h speed limits). The app led to good compliance with the posted speed limits, particularly during the 60 km/h road segment, where the control group drove at significantly higher speeds than the groups with the ISA app. No significant differences between the four versions of the ISA app were observed, either for speed compliance or the number of speeding alerts received. Across the entire simulated drive there were relatively few glances at the app with an average glance duration of 190 ms. The ISA app did not lead to any negative effects on driving performance; lane keeping was maintained and it did not impede participants’ ability to overtake vehicles. These findings suggest that when properly configured ISA apps have a demonstrable safety benefit and do not produce adverse distractive effects. The greatest challenge may be encouraging drivers’ to use them appropriately and consistently.

    KW - App

    KW - Distraction

    KW - Driver behaviour

    KW - Intelligent speed advisory

    KW - Speed

    KW - Technology

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85075765933&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.trc.2019.11.020

    DO - 10.1016/j.trc.2019.11.020

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:85075765933

    VL - 110

    SP - 209

    EP - 221

    JO - Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies

    JF - Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies

    SN - 0968-090X

    ER -