Empowering and engaging industrial workers with Operator 4.0 solutions

Eija Kaasinen (Corresponding Author), Franziska Schmalfuß, Cemalettin Özturk, Susanna Aromaa, Menouer Boubekeur, Juhani Heilala, Päivi Heikkilä, Timo Kuula, Marja Liinasuo, Sebastian Mach, Rakesh Mehta, Esko Petäjä, Thomas Walter

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    5 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Industry 4.0 has potential for qualitative enrichment of factory work: a more interesting working environment, greater autonomy and opportunities for self-development. A central element of Industry 4.0 is human-centricity, described as development towards Operator 4.0. Our Operator 4.0 vision includes smart factories of the future that are perfectly suited for workers with different skills, capabilities and preferences. The vision is achieved by solutions that empower the workers and engage the work community. Empowering the worker is based on adapting the factory shop floor to the skills, capabilities and needs of the worker and supporting the worker to understand and to develop his/her competence. Engaging the work community is based on tools, with which the workers can participate in designing their work and training, and share their knowledge with each other. We gathered requirements from three manufacturing companies in different industries and interviewed 44 workers in four factories in order to study their expectations and concerns related to the proposed Operator 4.0 solutions. Adaptation was considered useful both in manufacturing systems and in production planning. However, worker measuring and modelling raised many doubts within workers and also with factory management. Therefore it is important to provide early demonstrations of the ideas and to design them further with the workers in order to find acceptable and ethically sustainable ways for worker modelling. The workers would like to be more involved in the design of the work place and manufacturing processes, and they thought that participation would decrease many problems that they currently face in their work. However, there were also doubts concerning whether they really could have possibilities to impact on their work. The results show that there are clear needs for knowledge sharing and adaptive learning solutions that would support personalized competence development and learning while working. An easily accessible platform for knowledge sharing could evolve to a forum where good work practices and ways to solve problems are shared not only within the work community, but also with machine providers and other stakeholders. The interviewees saw the virtual factory as a promising platform for participatory design and training.

    Original languageEnglish
    Article number105678
    JournalComputers and Industrial Engineering
    Volume139
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Jan 2020
    MoE publication typeNot Eligible

    Fingerprint

    Industrial plants
    Industry
    Plant management
    Demonstrations
    Planning

    Keywords

    • Adaptation
    • Empowerment
    • Engagement
    • Factory automation
    • Factory work
    • Knowledge sharing
    • Participatory design
    • Training
    • User studies
    • Worker model

    Cite this

    Kaasinen, Eija ; Schmalfuß, Franziska ; Özturk, Cemalettin ; Aromaa, Susanna ; Boubekeur, Menouer ; Heilala, Juhani ; Heikkilä, Päivi ; Kuula, Timo ; Liinasuo, Marja ; Mach, Sebastian ; Mehta, Rakesh ; Petäjä, Esko ; Walter, Thomas. / Empowering and engaging industrial workers with Operator 4.0 solutions. In: Computers and Industrial Engineering. 2020 ; Vol. 139.
    @article{53ece488905c4cadabb2db624e655116,
    title = "Empowering and engaging industrial workers with Operator 4.0 solutions",
    abstract = "Industry 4.0 has potential for qualitative enrichment of factory work: a more interesting working environment, greater autonomy and opportunities for self-development. A central element of Industry 4.0 is human-centricity, described as development towards Operator 4.0. Our Operator 4.0 vision includes smart factories of the future that are perfectly suited for workers with different skills, capabilities and preferences. The vision is achieved by solutions that empower the workers and engage the work community. Empowering the worker is based on adapting the factory shop floor to the skills, capabilities and needs of the worker and supporting the worker to understand and to develop his/her competence. Engaging the work community is based on tools, with which the workers can participate in designing their work and training, and share their knowledge with each other. We gathered requirements from three manufacturing companies in different industries and interviewed 44 workers in four factories in order to study their expectations and concerns related to the proposed Operator 4.0 solutions. Adaptation was considered useful both in manufacturing systems and in production planning. However, worker measuring and modelling raised many doubts within workers and also with factory management. Therefore it is important to provide early demonstrations of the ideas and to design them further with the workers in order to find acceptable and ethically sustainable ways for worker modelling. The workers would like to be more involved in the design of the work place and manufacturing processes, and they thought that participation would decrease many problems that they currently face in their work. However, there were also doubts concerning whether they really could have possibilities to impact on their work. The results show that there are clear needs for knowledge sharing and adaptive learning solutions that would support personalized competence development and learning while working. An easily accessible platform for knowledge sharing could evolve to a forum where good work practices and ways to solve problems are shared not only within the work community, but also with machine providers and other stakeholders. The interviewees saw the virtual factory as a promising platform for participatory design and training.",
    keywords = "Adaptation, Empowerment, Engagement, Factory automation, Factory work, Knowledge sharing, Participatory design, Training, User studies, Worker model",
    author = "Eija Kaasinen and Franziska Schmalfu{\ss} and Cemalettin {\"O}zturk and Susanna Aromaa and Menouer Boubekeur and Juhani Heilala and P{\"a}ivi Heikkil{\"a} and Timo Kuula and Marja Liinasuo and Sebastian Mach and Rakesh Mehta and Esko Pet{\"a}j{\"a} and Thomas Walter",
    year = "2020",
    month = "1",
    doi = "10.1016/j.cie.2019.01.052",
    language = "English",
    volume = "139",
    journal = "Computers and Industrial Engineering",
    issn = "0360-8352",
    publisher = "Elsevier",

    }

    Empowering and engaging industrial workers with Operator 4.0 solutions. / Kaasinen, Eija (Corresponding Author); Schmalfuß, Franziska; Özturk, Cemalettin; Aromaa, Susanna; Boubekeur, Menouer; Heilala, Juhani; Heikkilä, Päivi; Kuula, Timo; Liinasuo, Marja; Mach, Sebastian; Mehta, Rakesh; Petäjä, Esko; Walter, Thomas.

    In: Computers and Industrial Engineering, Vol. 139, 105678, 01.2020.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Empowering and engaging industrial workers with Operator 4.0 solutions

    AU - Kaasinen, Eija

    AU - Schmalfuß, Franziska

    AU - Özturk, Cemalettin

    AU - Aromaa, Susanna

    AU - Boubekeur, Menouer

    AU - Heilala, Juhani

    AU - Heikkilä, Päivi

    AU - Kuula, Timo

    AU - Liinasuo, Marja

    AU - Mach, Sebastian

    AU - Mehta, Rakesh

    AU - Petäjä, Esko

    AU - Walter, Thomas

    PY - 2020/1

    Y1 - 2020/1

    N2 - Industry 4.0 has potential for qualitative enrichment of factory work: a more interesting working environment, greater autonomy and opportunities for self-development. A central element of Industry 4.0 is human-centricity, described as development towards Operator 4.0. Our Operator 4.0 vision includes smart factories of the future that are perfectly suited for workers with different skills, capabilities and preferences. The vision is achieved by solutions that empower the workers and engage the work community. Empowering the worker is based on adapting the factory shop floor to the skills, capabilities and needs of the worker and supporting the worker to understand and to develop his/her competence. Engaging the work community is based on tools, with which the workers can participate in designing their work and training, and share their knowledge with each other. We gathered requirements from three manufacturing companies in different industries and interviewed 44 workers in four factories in order to study their expectations and concerns related to the proposed Operator 4.0 solutions. Adaptation was considered useful both in manufacturing systems and in production planning. However, worker measuring and modelling raised many doubts within workers and also with factory management. Therefore it is important to provide early demonstrations of the ideas and to design them further with the workers in order to find acceptable and ethically sustainable ways for worker modelling. The workers would like to be more involved in the design of the work place and manufacturing processes, and they thought that participation would decrease many problems that they currently face in their work. However, there were also doubts concerning whether they really could have possibilities to impact on their work. The results show that there are clear needs for knowledge sharing and adaptive learning solutions that would support personalized competence development and learning while working. An easily accessible platform for knowledge sharing could evolve to a forum where good work practices and ways to solve problems are shared not only within the work community, but also with machine providers and other stakeholders. The interviewees saw the virtual factory as a promising platform for participatory design and training.

    AB - Industry 4.0 has potential for qualitative enrichment of factory work: a more interesting working environment, greater autonomy and opportunities for self-development. A central element of Industry 4.0 is human-centricity, described as development towards Operator 4.0. Our Operator 4.0 vision includes smart factories of the future that are perfectly suited for workers with different skills, capabilities and preferences. The vision is achieved by solutions that empower the workers and engage the work community. Empowering the worker is based on adapting the factory shop floor to the skills, capabilities and needs of the worker and supporting the worker to understand and to develop his/her competence. Engaging the work community is based on tools, with which the workers can participate in designing their work and training, and share their knowledge with each other. We gathered requirements from three manufacturing companies in different industries and interviewed 44 workers in four factories in order to study their expectations and concerns related to the proposed Operator 4.0 solutions. Adaptation was considered useful both in manufacturing systems and in production planning. However, worker measuring and modelling raised many doubts within workers and also with factory management. Therefore it is important to provide early demonstrations of the ideas and to design them further with the workers in order to find acceptable and ethically sustainable ways for worker modelling. The workers would like to be more involved in the design of the work place and manufacturing processes, and they thought that participation would decrease many problems that they currently face in their work. However, there were also doubts concerning whether they really could have possibilities to impact on their work. The results show that there are clear needs for knowledge sharing and adaptive learning solutions that would support personalized competence development and learning while working. An easily accessible platform for knowledge sharing could evolve to a forum where good work practices and ways to solve problems are shared not only within the work community, but also with machine providers and other stakeholders. The interviewees saw the virtual factory as a promising platform for participatory design and training.

    KW - Adaptation

    KW - Empowerment

    KW - Engagement

    KW - Factory automation

    KW - Factory work

    KW - Knowledge sharing

    KW - Participatory design

    KW - Training

    KW - User studies

    KW - Worker model

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85061040878&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.cie.2019.01.052

    DO - 10.1016/j.cie.2019.01.052

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:85061040878

    VL - 139

    JO - Computers and Industrial Engineering

    JF - Computers and Industrial Engineering

    SN - 0360-8352

    M1 - 105678

    ER -