Evaluation of Overall Effectiveness Measurements in a wind farm: An approach to assess life cycle system effectiveness

Idriss El-Thalji, Erkki Jantunen

    Research output: Contribution to conferenceConference articleScientific

    Abstract

    This paper describes current Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) figures and evaluates the practices of performance measurement within Nordic wind farms. A traditional OEE approach is utilised to describe the current performance measures of wind farms in Nordic context, however, it lacks to evaluate the healthiness and health losses (i.e. losses due to faster deterioration rate compared to expected design rating) beside the availability, performance and quality losses. For instance, when a wind turbine deteriorates before the expected lifetime it is extremely significant to show through the utilisation figures high values of availability, performance and quality within that time interval. This approach has been applied based on actual data from two selected wind farms. Results show that health losses due to electricity generation under harsh loading and operating condition has the largest share of total operational losses which do not include health losses due to the assumption of the deterioration equality (i.e. in each year) and the satisfaction of design rating (i.e. expected lifetime rating). The life cycle approach for OEE highlights the value of asset together with its production effectiveness.
    Original languageEnglish
    Publication statusPublished - 2012
    MoE publication typeNot Eligible
    Event2nd International Congress on Maintenance, Performance, Measurement & Management; MPMM 2012 - Sunderland, United Kingdom
    Duration: 12 Sep 201213 Sep 2012

    Conference

    Conference2nd International Congress on Maintenance, Performance, Measurement & Management; MPMM 2012
    Abbreviated titleMPMM 2012
    CountryUnited Kingdom
    CitySunderland
    Period12/09/1213/09/12

    Fingerprint

    Farms
    Life cycle
    Health
    Deterioration
    Availability
    Wind turbines
    Electricity

    Keywords

    • OEE
    • asset effectiveness
    • lifecycle
    • wind energy

    Cite this

    El-Thalji, I., & Jantunen, E. (2012). Evaluation of Overall Effectiveness Measurements in a wind farm: An approach to assess life cycle system effectiveness. Paper presented at 2nd International Congress on Maintenance, Performance, Measurement & Management; MPMM 2012, Sunderland, United Kingdom.
    El-Thalji, Idriss ; Jantunen, Erkki. / Evaluation of Overall Effectiveness Measurements in a wind farm : An approach to assess life cycle system effectiveness. Paper presented at 2nd International Congress on Maintenance, Performance, Measurement & Management; MPMM 2012, Sunderland, United Kingdom.
    @conference{94afbcd37c724ae4b0bb74284ecdab5b,
    title = "Evaluation of Overall Effectiveness Measurements in a wind farm: An approach to assess life cycle system effectiveness",
    abstract = "This paper describes current Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) figures and evaluates the practices of performance measurement within Nordic wind farms. A traditional OEE approach is utilised to describe the current performance measures of wind farms in Nordic context, however, it lacks to evaluate the healthiness and health losses (i.e. losses due to faster deterioration rate compared to expected design rating) beside the availability, performance and quality losses. For instance, when a wind turbine deteriorates before the expected lifetime it is extremely significant to show through the utilisation figures high values of availability, performance and quality within that time interval. This approach has been applied based on actual data from two selected wind farms. Results show that health losses due to electricity generation under harsh loading and operating condition has the largest share of total operational losses which do not include health losses due to the assumption of the deterioration equality (i.e. in each year) and the satisfaction of design rating (i.e. expected lifetime rating). The life cycle approach for OEE highlights the value of asset together with its production effectiveness.",
    keywords = "OEE, asset effectiveness, lifecycle, wind energy",
    author = "Idriss El-Thalji and Erkki Jantunen",
    note = "Project code: 76753; 2nd International Congress on Maintenance, Performance, Measurement & Management; MPMM 2012, MPMM 2012 ; Conference date: 12-09-2012 Through 13-09-2012",
    year = "2012",
    language = "English",

    }

    El-Thalji, I & Jantunen, E 2012, 'Evaluation of Overall Effectiveness Measurements in a wind farm: An approach to assess life cycle system effectiveness', Paper presented at 2nd International Congress on Maintenance, Performance, Measurement & Management; MPMM 2012, Sunderland, United Kingdom, 12/09/12 - 13/09/12.

    Evaluation of Overall Effectiveness Measurements in a wind farm : An approach to assess life cycle system effectiveness. / El-Thalji, Idriss; Jantunen, Erkki.

    2012. Paper presented at 2nd International Congress on Maintenance, Performance, Measurement & Management; MPMM 2012, Sunderland, United Kingdom.

    Research output: Contribution to conferenceConference articleScientific

    TY - CONF

    T1 - Evaluation of Overall Effectiveness Measurements in a wind farm

    T2 - An approach to assess life cycle system effectiveness

    AU - El-Thalji, Idriss

    AU - Jantunen, Erkki

    N1 - Project code: 76753

    PY - 2012

    Y1 - 2012

    N2 - This paper describes current Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) figures and evaluates the practices of performance measurement within Nordic wind farms. A traditional OEE approach is utilised to describe the current performance measures of wind farms in Nordic context, however, it lacks to evaluate the healthiness and health losses (i.e. losses due to faster deterioration rate compared to expected design rating) beside the availability, performance and quality losses. For instance, when a wind turbine deteriorates before the expected lifetime it is extremely significant to show through the utilisation figures high values of availability, performance and quality within that time interval. This approach has been applied based on actual data from two selected wind farms. Results show that health losses due to electricity generation under harsh loading and operating condition has the largest share of total operational losses which do not include health losses due to the assumption of the deterioration equality (i.e. in each year) and the satisfaction of design rating (i.e. expected lifetime rating). The life cycle approach for OEE highlights the value of asset together with its production effectiveness.

    AB - This paper describes current Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) figures and evaluates the practices of performance measurement within Nordic wind farms. A traditional OEE approach is utilised to describe the current performance measures of wind farms in Nordic context, however, it lacks to evaluate the healthiness and health losses (i.e. losses due to faster deterioration rate compared to expected design rating) beside the availability, performance and quality losses. For instance, when a wind turbine deteriorates before the expected lifetime it is extremely significant to show through the utilisation figures high values of availability, performance and quality within that time interval. This approach has been applied based on actual data from two selected wind farms. Results show that health losses due to electricity generation under harsh loading and operating condition has the largest share of total operational losses which do not include health losses due to the assumption of the deterioration equality (i.e. in each year) and the satisfaction of design rating (i.e. expected lifetime rating). The life cycle approach for OEE highlights the value of asset together with its production effectiveness.

    KW - OEE

    KW - asset effectiveness

    KW - lifecycle

    KW - wind energy

    M3 - Conference article

    ER -

    El-Thalji I, Jantunen E. Evaluation of Overall Effectiveness Measurements in a wind farm: An approach to assess life cycle system effectiveness. 2012. Paper presented at 2nd International Congress on Maintenance, Performance, Measurement & Management; MPMM 2012, Sunderland, United Kingdom.