Identifying resilience in proceduralised accident management activity of NPP operating crews

Paula Savioja, Leena Norros, Leena Salo, Iina Aaltonen

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    17 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    This paper reports a study in which the usage of emergency operating procedures (EOP) in a simulated accident scenario in a nuclear power plant was carefully analysed. The background assumption was that in an accident situation, even within the closely defined envelope of the EOPs, crews may act differently. The empirical findings demonstrate the variance in the operating performance of twelve professional crews all complying with the EOP. The variance was identified by analysing how crews acted in situations and what particular meanings they associated to the situations. Variance was identified in six tasks: information usage, situation identification, dealing with automation, decision making, communication, and leadership. Corresponding habits, the operationalizations of practices, were identified in the analysis. The discovered operating practices in EOP usage were analysed from the point of view of increasing system level resilience. For example, a strong inclination towards connecting operations with process responses will eventually increase the capability of the whole system to adapt to external disturbances. The conclusion is that on a micro-level the activities of crews are different even within EOP following and also, that some practices seem to have more capability produce resilience in the system. A practical implication is that in the training of proceduralized work, attention should be paid to integrating the EOP usage to the operating work, not only to adherence to the procedure. The contribution of the paper is the insight into the role of proceduralized tasks in the construction of resilient emergency operating activity.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)258-274
    Number of pages17
    JournalSafety Science
    Volume68
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2014
    MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

    Fingerprint

    resilience
    Accidents
    accident
    Emergencies
    management
    Nuclear power plants
    Identification (control systems)
    Automation
    Decision making
    Communication
    Nuclear Power Plants
    nuclear power plant
    operationalization
    micro level
    automation
    Habits
    habits
    Decision Making
    leadership
    scenario

    Keywords

    • Emergency operating procedures
    • Habit of action
    • Nuclear power plant operation
    • Practice approach
    • Resilience

    Cite this

    Savioja, Paula ; Norros, Leena ; Salo, Leena ; Aaltonen, Iina. / Identifying resilience in proceduralised accident management activity of NPP operating crews. In: Safety Science. 2014 ; Vol. 68. pp. 258-274.
    @article{11e3cee81b284ffcb180f74d1c038e5d,
    title = "Identifying resilience in proceduralised accident management activity of NPP operating crews",
    abstract = "This paper reports a study in which the usage of emergency operating procedures (EOP) in a simulated accident scenario in a nuclear power plant was carefully analysed. The background assumption was that in an accident situation, even within the closely defined envelope of the EOPs, crews may act differently. The empirical findings demonstrate the variance in the operating performance of twelve professional crews all complying with the EOP. The variance was identified by analysing how crews acted in situations and what particular meanings they associated to the situations. Variance was identified in six tasks: information usage, situation identification, dealing with automation, decision making, communication, and leadership. Corresponding habits, the operationalizations of practices, were identified in the analysis. The discovered operating practices in EOP usage were analysed from the point of view of increasing system level resilience. For example, a strong inclination towards connecting operations with process responses will eventually increase the capability of the whole system to adapt to external disturbances. The conclusion is that on a micro-level the activities of crews are different even within EOP following and also, that some practices seem to have more capability produce resilience in the system. A practical implication is that in the training of proceduralized work, attention should be paid to integrating the EOP usage to the operating work, not only to adherence to the procedure. The contribution of the paper is the insight into the role of proceduralized tasks in the construction of resilient emergency operating activity.",
    keywords = "Emergency operating procedures, Habit of action, Nuclear power plant operation, Practice approach, Resilience",
    author = "Paula Savioja and Leena Norros and Leena Salo and Iina Aaltonen",
    year = "2014",
    month = "1",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1016/j.ssci.2014.04.008",
    language = "English",
    volume = "68",
    pages = "258--274",
    journal = "Safety Science",
    issn = "0925-7535",
    publisher = "Elsevier",

    }

    Identifying resilience in proceduralised accident management activity of NPP operating crews. / Savioja, Paula; Norros, Leena; Salo, Leena; Aaltonen, Iina.

    In: Safety Science, Vol. 68, 01.01.2014, p. 258-274.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Identifying resilience in proceduralised accident management activity of NPP operating crews

    AU - Savioja, Paula

    AU - Norros, Leena

    AU - Salo, Leena

    AU - Aaltonen, Iina

    PY - 2014/1/1

    Y1 - 2014/1/1

    N2 - This paper reports a study in which the usage of emergency operating procedures (EOP) in a simulated accident scenario in a nuclear power plant was carefully analysed. The background assumption was that in an accident situation, even within the closely defined envelope of the EOPs, crews may act differently. The empirical findings demonstrate the variance in the operating performance of twelve professional crews all complying with the EOP. The variance was identified by analysing how crews acted in situations and what particular meanings they associated to the situations. Variance was identified in six tasks: information usage, situation identification, dealing with automation, decision making, communication, and leadership. Corresponding habits, the operationalizations of practices, were identified in the analysis. The discovered operating practices in EOP usage were analysed from the point of view of increasing system level resilience. For example, a strong inclination towards connecting operations with process responses will eventually increase the capability of the whole system to adapt to external disturbances. The conclusion is that on a micro-level the activities of crews are different even within EOP following and also, that some practices seem to have more capability produce resilience in the system. A practical implication is that in the training of proceduralized work, attention should be paid to integrating the EOP usage to the operating work, not only to adherence to the procedure. The contribution of the paper is the insight into the role of proceduralized tasks in the construction of resilient emergency operating activity.

    AB - This paper reports a study in which the usage of emergency operating procedures (EOP) in a simulated accident scenario in a nuclear power plant was carefully analysed. The background assumption was that in an accident situation, even within the closely defined envelope of the EOPs, crews may act differently. The empirical findings demonstrate the variance in the operating performance of twelve professional crews all complying with the EOP. The variance was identified by analysing how crews acted in situations and what particular meanings they associated to the situations. Variance was identified in six tasks: information usage, situation identification, dealing with automation, decision making, communication, and leadership. Corresponding habits, the operationalizations of practices, were identified in the analysis. The discovered operating practices in EOP usage were analysed from the point of view of increasing system level resilience. For example, a strong inclination towards connecting operations with process responses will eventually increase the capability of the whole system to adapt to external disturbances. The conclusion is that on a micro-level the activities of crews are different even within EOP following and also, that some practices seem to have more capability produce resilience in the system. A practical implication is that in the training of proceduralized work, attention should be paid to integrating the EOP usage to the operating work, not only to adherence to the procedure. The contribution of the paper is the insight into the role of proceduralized tasks in the construction of resilient emergency operating activity.

    KW - Emergency operating procedures

    KW - Habit of action

    KW - Nuclear power plant operation

    KW - Practice approach

    KW - Resilience

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84899869889&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.ssci.2014.04.008

    DO - 10.1016/j.ssci.2014.04.008

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:84899869889

    VL - 68

    SP - 258

    EP - 274

    JO - Safety Science

    JF - Safety Science

    SN - 0925-7535

    ER -