International comparison of a depletion calculation benchmark devoted to fuel cycle issues Results from the Phase 1 dedicated to PWR-UOx fuels

B. Roque, R. Gregg, R. Kilger, P. Marimbeau, Anssu Ranta-Aho, C. Riffard, K. Suyama, J.F. Thro, M. Yudkevich, K. Hesketh, E. Sartori

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientificpeer-review

Abstract

This paper presents the results from the first phase of an international depletion calculations comparison devoted to PWR-UOx fuel cycle issues. This 'benchmark' has been defined within the NEA/OECD Working Party on Scientific Issues in Reactors Systems (WPRS). The aim is to investigate a large range of isotopes, physics quantities and fuel types applied to fuel and back-end cycle configurations. The results analyses have shown that there is a good agreement between participants for the mass calculation of many isotopes. However, it is interesting to observe that better agreement is obtained for isotopes which benefit from experimental validation. In this benchmark, the poorest agreement is obtained in calculating activation products originating from fuel impurities. Some discrepancies on neutron emission rates were also observed, mainly due to the discrepancies on masses calculations. Good agreement was obtained for the total decay heat calculation.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationAmerican Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics. PHYSOR-2006. Vancouver, Canada, 10 - 14 Sept. 2006
PublisherAmerican Nuclear Society ANS
Number of pages10
ISBN (Print)0-89448-697-7
Publication statusPublished - 2006
MoE publication typeA4 Article in a conference publication
EventAmerican Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics - Advances in Nuclear Analysis and Simulation, PHYSOR-2006 - Vancouver, Canada
Duration: 10 Sep 200614 Sep 2006

Conference

ConferenceAmerican Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics - Advances in Nuclear Analysis and Simulation, PHYSOR-2006
CountryCanada
CityVancouver
Period10/09/0614/09/06

Fingerprint

depletion
cycles
isotopes
neutron emission
reactors
activation
heat
impurities
physics
decay
products
configurations

Cite this

Roque, B., Gregg, R., Kilger, R., Marimbeau, P., Ranta-Aho, A., Riffard, C., ... Sartori, E. (2006). International comparison of a depletion calculation benchmark devoted to fuel cycle issues Results from the Phase 1 dedicated to PWR-UOx fuels. In American Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics. PHYSOR-2006. Vancouver, Canada, 10 - 14 Sept. 2006 American Nuclear Society ANS.
Roque, B. ; Gregg, R. ; Kilger, R. ; Marimbeau, P. ; Ranta-Aho, Anssu ; Riffard, C. ; Suyama, K. ; Thro, J.F. ; Yudkevich, M. ; Hesketh, K. ; Sartori, E. / International comparison of a depletion calculation benchmark devoted to fuel cycle issues Results from the Phase 1 dedicated to PWR-UOx fuels. American Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics. PHYSOR-2006. Vancouver, Canada, 10 - 14 Sept. 2006. American Nuclear Society ANS, 2006.
@inproceedings{51ac089e18444de38b53fd52ad5ea71c,
title = "International comparison of a depletion calculation benchmark devoted to fuel cycle issues Results from the Phase 1 dedicated to PWR-UOx fuels",
abstract = "This paper presents the results from the first phase of an international depletion calculations comparison devoted to PWR-UOx fuel cycle issues. This 'benchmark' has been defined within the NEA/OECD Working Party on Scientific Issues in Reactors Systems (WPRS). The aim is to investigate a large range of isotopes, physics quantities and fuel types applied to fuel and back-end cycle configurations. The results analyses have shown that there is a good agreement between participants for the mass calculation of many isotopes. However, it is interesting to observe that better agreement is obtained for isotopes which benefit from experimental validation. In this benchmark, the poorest agreement is obtained in calculating activation products originating from fuel impurities. Some discrepancies on neutron emission rates were also observed, mainly due to the discrepancies on masses calculations. Good agreement was obtained for the total decay heat calculation.",
author = "B. Roque and R. Gregg and R. Kilger and P. Marimbeau and Anssu Ranta-Aho and C. Riffard and K. Suyama and J.F. Thro and M. Yudkevich and K. Hesketh and E. Sartori",
year = "2006",
language = "English",
isbn = "0-89448-697-7",
booktitle = "American Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics. PHYSOR-2006. Vancouver, Canada, 10 - 14 Sept. 2006",
publisher = "American Nuclear Society ANS",
address = "United States",

}

Roque, B, Gregg, R, Kilger, R, Marimbeau, P, Ranta-Aho, A, Riffard, C, Suyama, K, Thro, JF, Yudkevich, M, Hesketh, K & Sartori, E 2006, International comparison of a depletion calculation benchmark devoted to fuel cycle issues Results from the Phase 1 dedicated to PWR-UOx fuels. in American Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics. PHYSOR-2006. Vancouver, Canada, 10 - 14 Sept. 2006. American Nuclear Society ANS, American Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics - Advances in Nuclear Analysis and Simulation, PHYSOR-2006, Vancouver, Canada, 10/09/06.

International comparison of a depletion calculation benchmark devoted to fuel cycle issues Results from the Phase 1 dedicated to PWR-UOx fuels. / Roque, B.; Gregg, R.; Kilger, R.; Marimbeau, P.; Ranta-Aho, Anssu; Riffard, C.; Suyama, K.; Thro, J.F.; Yudkevich, M.; Hesketh, K.; Sartori, E.

American Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics. PHYSOR-2006. Vancouver, Canada, 10 - 14 Sept. 2006. American Nuclear Society ANS, 2006.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientificpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - International comparison of a depletion calculation benchmark devoted to fuel cycle issues Results from the Phase 1 dedicated to PWR-UOx fuels

AU - Roque, B.

AU - Gregg, R.

AU - Kilger, R.

AU - Marimbeau, P.

AU - Ranta-Aho, Anssu

AU - Riffard, C.

AU - Suyama, K.

AU - Thro, J.F.

AU - Yudkevich, M.

AU - Hesketh, K.

AU - Sartori, E.

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - This paper presents the results from the first phase of an international depletion calculations comparison devoted to PWR-UOx fuel cycle issues. This 'benchmark' has been defined within the NEA/OECD Working Party on Scientific Issues in Reactors Systems (WPRS). The aim is to investigate a large range of isotopes, physics quantities and fuel types applied to fuel and back-end cycle configurations. The results analyses have shown that there is a good agreement between participants for the mass calculation of many isotopes. However, it is interesting to observe that better agreement is obtained for isotopes which benefit from experimental validation. In this benchmark, the poorest agreement is obtained in calculating activation products originating from fuel impurities. Some discrepancies on neutron emission rates were also observed, mainly due to the discrepancies on masses calculations. Good agreement was obtained for the total decay heat calculation.

AB - This paper presents the results from the first phase of an international depletion calculations comparison devoted to PWR-UOx fuel cycle issues. This 'benchmark' has been defined within the NEA/OECD Working Party on Scientific Issues in Reactors Systems (WPRS). The aim is to investigate a large range of isotopes, physics quantities and fuel types applied to fuel and back-end cycle configurations. The results analyses have shown that there is a good agreement between participants for the mass calculation of many isotopes. However, it is interesting to observe that better agreement is obtained for isotopes which benefit from experimental validation. In this benchmark, the poorest agreement is obtained in calculating activation products originating from fuel impurities. Some discrepancies on neutron emission rates were also observed, mainly due to the discrepancies on masses calculations. Good agreement was obtained for the total decay heat calculation.

M3 - Conference article in proceedings

SN - 0-89448-697-7

BT - American Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics. PHYSOR-2006. Vancouver, Canada, 10 - 14 Sept. 2006

PB - American Nuclear Society ANS

ER -

Roque B, Gregg R, Kilger R, Marimbeau P, Ranta-Aho A, Riffard C et al. International comparison of a depletion calculation benchmark devoted to fuel cycle issues Results from the Phase 1 dedicated to PWR-UOx fuels. In American Nuclear Society's Topical Meeting on Reactor Physics. PHYSOR-2006. Vancouver, Canada, 10 - 14 Sept. 2006. American Nuclear Society ANS. 2006