Modelling super-equilibrium in biomass gasification with the constrained gibbs energy method

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Background: Biomass gasification can be seen as a viable option for generating electricity from biomass with high efficiency or for the production of liquid biofuels and chemicals. Gasification is a thermo-chemical conversion process that takes place at high temperature and reductive environment. For such conditions thermodynamic equilibrium is often assumed, but not reached in practice: during biomass gasification light hydrocarbons (e.g.: CH4, C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, C3H8, C6H6), ammonia, tars and char are also formed. These phenomena cannot usually be modelled with equilibrium assumptions. In order to increase the accuracy of gasification models, both empirical and mechanistic models are often applied alone or combined with thermodynamic equilibrium calculations [1]. This leads to a 'dual' approach where different parts of the process and reactions are modelled independently and results are merged in postprocessing. This study presents a unified solution for simultaneous calculation of the super-equilibrium reactions and related reaction enthalpies in the gasification process. The solution is based on the Constrained Free Energy (CFE) method where equilibrium computation is extended with additional immaterial constraints for solving the local or partial constrained equilibrium instead of the global thermodynamic equilibrium.

Methodology: First applications of the constrained thermodynamic equilibrium method in Gibbs energy minimization were the conservation of immaterial properties [2] and inclusion of reaction kinetics into the Gibbs'ian multicomponent models [3,4]. In the course of time the method has found new applications, ranging from modelling sorption in pulp suspensions to determining surface tension of liquid mixtures [5]. Quite recently CFE has been used to estimate the super-equilibria of alkali metals and sulphur in black liquor combustion [6]. Today constrained free energy method is seen as a versatile tool for various fields of application. In this study the CFE methodology is applied for describing the super-equilibrium occurring in biomass gasification. Light hydrocarbons, ammonia, tars and char tend to decompose if thermodynamic equilibrium calculation is performed for high temperatures, and thus constraints are needed for the modelling of their presence in the super-equilibrium conditions. This a computational study with all experimental data obtained from literature. The empirical model of super-equilibrium applied is from [1]. Thermodynamic data is from [7]. ChemSheet [8] is used as the modelling tool as it allows extending the thermodynamic system and thus enables the calculations of constrained free energy models.

Results: In the present work different approaches for the modelling of global or local equilibrium of biomass gasification have been assessed. First (i) thermodynamic equilibrium without any constraints is computed and used as reference. Later additional constraints are introduced to system, such as amount of (ii) char, (iii) tars, (iv) ammonia. The light hydrocarbons are defined by (v) the amount of carbon and by (vi) amount of hydrogen in hydrocarbons. In addition constraints such as (vii) amount of double bonds in hydrocarbons or (viii) methane amount are evaluated. Finally a fully constrained system, where all species are defined according to [1] is reported. The super-equilibrium of major syngas components (CO, CO2, H2, H2O and CH4) can be predicted with the proposed constrained free energy method. Accuracy of the model increases when an additional constraint for hydrogen in hydrocarbons is defined. At the same time the partial equilibrium moves further from the global equilibrium. While the adapted constraints were successful in evaluating the super-equilibrium of major species, the respective predictions for minor hydrocarbon components (C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, C3H8, C6H6) were not as satisfying. The selection of modelled light hydrocarbon components seems to be vital, if more accuracy is required. In addition by defining all species with separate constraints, it is possible to increase the accuracy of results, but with the cost of decreasing the degrees of freedom of the thermodynamic system.

Summary: Constrained free energy method was successfully applied for the calculation of the super-equilibrium of light hydrocarbons, ammonia, tars and char in biomass gasification. Gasification can be solved as restricted partial equilibrium with a single calculation step. Thus, there is no need for post-processing corrections for e.g. volume or enthalpy flows. For a reasonable accuracy of the simulation model, it is not necessary to define constraints for all reactions, but a set of more general constraints (e.g. carbon in hydrocarbons) remain sufficient. Distinct benefit of presented approach is that chemical reactions, gasification enthalpy and states of the system (such as volume) are estimated concurrently. This method is also resilient: the number of details describing constraints can vary from simpler experimental results and models to complicated mechanistic models. A promising application area for the presented methodology could be as part of large scale process simulation where detailed thermodynamic models can be implemented and effects in gasification chemistry could conduct changes in the entire process.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationComputational Molecular Science and Engineering Forum 2013 - Core Programming Area at the 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting
Subtitle of host publicationGlobal Challenges for Engineering a Sustainable Future
PublisherAmerican Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE
Pages211-213
Number of pages3
ISBN (Electronic)9781634390354
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2013
MoE publication typeNot Eligible
Event2013 AIChE Annual Meeting: Global Challenges for Engineering a Sustainable Future - San Francisco, CA, United States
Duration: 3 Nov 20138 Nov 2013

Conference

Conference2013 AIChE Annual Meeting
Abbreviated title13AIChE
CountryUnited States
CitySan Francisco, CA
Period3/11/138/11/13

Fingerprint

Energy Method
Gibbs free energy
Biomass
Gasification
Hydrocarbons
Thermodynamics
Free energy
Thermodynamic Equilibrium
Modeling
Tars
Free Energy
Tar
Ammonia
Enthalpy
Empirical Model
Hydrogen
Carbon
Post-processing
Partial
Methodology

Cite this

Kangas, P., Koukkari, P., & Hannula, I. (2013). Modelling super-equilibrium in biomass gasification with the constrained gibbs energy method. In Computational Molecular Science and Engineering Forum 2013 - Core Programming Area at the 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting: Global Challenges for Engineering a Sustainable Future (pp. 211-213). American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE.
Kangas, P. ; Koukkari, P. ; Hannula, I. / Modelling super-equilibrium in biomass gasification with the constrained gibbs energy method. Computational Molecular Science and Engineering Forum 2013 - Core Programming Area at the 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting: Global Challenges for Engineering a Sustainable Future. American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE, 2013. pp. 211-213
@inproceedings{a9aba04b97fc4347bed093d274b7673e,
title = "Modelling super-equilibrium in biomass gasification with the constrained gibbs energy method",
abstract = "Background: Biomass gasification can be seen as a viable option for generating electricity from biomass with high efficiency or for the production of liquid biofuels and chemicals. Gasification is a thermo-chemical conversion process that takes place at high temperature and reductive environment. For such conditions thermodynamic equilibrium is often assumed, but not reached in practice: during biomass gasification light hydrocarbons (e.g.: CH4, C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, C3H8, C6H6), ammonia, tars and char are also formed. These phenomena cannot usually be modelled with equilibrium assumptions. In order to increase the accuracy of gasification models, both empirical and mechanistic models are often applied alone or combined with thermodynamic equilibrium calculations [1]. This leads to a 'dual' approach where different parts of the process and reactions are modelled independently and results are merged in postprocessing. This study presents a unified solution for simultaneous calculation of the super-equilibrium reactions and related reaction enthalpies in the gasification process. The solution is based on the Constrained Free Energy (CFE) method where equilibrium computation is extended with additional immaterial constraints for solving the local or partial constrained equilibrium instead of the global thermodynamic equilibrium.Methodology: First applications of the constrained thermodynamic equilibrium method in Gibbs energy minimization were the conservation of immaterial properties [2] and inclusion of reaction kinetics into the Gibbs'ian multicomponent models [3,4]. In the course of time the method has found new applications, ranging from modelling sorption in pulp suspensions to determining surface tension of liquid mixtures [5]. Quite recently CFE has been used to estimate the super-equilibria of alkali metals and sulphur in black liquor combustion [6]. Today constrained free energy method is seen as a versatile tool for various fields of application. In this study the CFE methodology is applied for describing the super-equilibrium occurring in biomass gasification. Light hydrocarbons, ammonia, tars and char tend to decompose if thermodynamic equilibrium calculation is performed for high temperatures, and thus constraints are needed for the modelling of their presence in the super-equilibrium conditions. This a computational study with all experimental data obtained from literature. The empirical model of super-equilibrium applied is from [1]. Thermodynamic data is from [7]. ChemSheet [8] is used as the modelling tool as it allows extending the thermodynamic system and thus enables the calculations of constrained free energy models.Results: In the present work different approaches for the modelling of global or local equilibrium of biomass gasification have been assessed. First (i) thermodynamic equilibrium without any constraints is computed and used as reference. Later additional constraints are introduced to system, such as amount of (ii) char, (iii) tars, (iv) ammonia. The light hydrocarbons are defined by (v) the amount of carbon and by (vi) amount of hydrogen in hydrocarbons. In addition constraints such as (vii) amount of double bonds in hydrocarbons or (viii) methane amount are evaluated. Finally a fully constrained system, where all species are defined according to [1] is reported. The super-equilibrium of major syngas components (CO, CO2, H2, H2O and CH4) can be predicted with the proposed constrained free energy method. Accuracy of the model increases when an additional constraint for hydrogen in hydrocarbons is defined. At the same time the partial equilibrium moves further from the global equilibrium. While the adapted constraints were successful in evaluating the super-equilibrium of major species, the respective predictions for minor hydrocarbon components (C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, C3H8, C6H6) were not as satisfying. The selection of modelled light hydrocarbon components seems to be vital, if more accuracy is required. In addition by defining all species with separate constraints, it is possible to increase the accuracy of results, but with the cost of decreasing the degrees of freedom of the thermodynamic system.Summary: Constrained free energy method was successfully applied for the calculation of the super-equilibrium of light hydrocarbons, ammonia, tars and char in biomass gasification. Gasification can be solved as restricted partial equilibrium with a single calculation step. Thus, there is no need for post-processing corrections for e.g. volume or enthalpy flows. For a reasonable accuracy of the simulation model, it is not necessary to define constraints for all reactions, but a set of more general constraints (e.g. carbon in hydrocarbons) remain sufficient. Distinct benefit of presented approach is that chemical reactions, gasification enthalpy and states of the system (such as volume) are estimated concurrently. This method is also resilient: the number of details describing constraints can vary from simpler experimental results and models to complicated mechanistic models. A promising application area for the presented methodology could be as part of large scale process simulation where detailed thermodynamic models can be implemented and effects in gasification chemistry could conduct changes in the entire process.",
author = "P. Kangas and P. Koukkari and I. Hannula",
year = "2013",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
pages = "211--213",
booktitle = "Computational Molecular Science and Engineering Forum 2013 - Core Programming Area at the 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting",
publisher = "American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE",
address = "United States",

}

Kangas, P, Koukkari, P & Hannula, I 2013, Modelling super-equilibrium in biomass gasification with the constrained gibbs energy method. in Computational Molecular Science and Engineering Forum 2013 - Core Programming Area at the 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting: Global Challenges for Engineering a Sustainable Future. American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE, pp. 211-213, 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting, San Francisco, CA, United States, 3/11/13.

Modelling super-equilibrium in biomass gasification with the constrained gibbs energy method. / Kangas, P.; Koukkari, P.; Hannula, I.

Computational Molecular Science and Engineering Forum 2013 - Core Programming Area at the 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting: Global Challenges for Engineering a Sustainable Future. American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE, 2013. p. 211-213.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientificpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Modelling super-equilibrium in biomass gasification with the constrained gibbs energy method

AU - Kangas, P.

AU - Koukkari, P.

AU - Hannula, I.

PY - 2013/1/1

Y1 - 2013/1/1

N2 - Background: Biomass gasification can be seen as a viable option for generating electricity from biomass with high efficiency or for the production of liquid biofuels and chemicals. Gasification is a thermo-chemical conversion process that takes place at high temperature and reductive environment. For such conditions thermodynamic equilibrium is often assumed, but not reached in practice: during biomass gasification light hydrocarbons (e.g.: CH4, C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, C3H8, C6H6), ammonia, tars and char are also formed. These phenomena cannot usually be modelled with equilibrium assumptions. In order to increase the accuracy of gasification models, both empirical and mechanistic models are often applied alone or combined with thermodynamic equilibrium calculations [1]. This leads to a 'dual' approach where different parts of the process and reactions are modelled independently and results are merged in postprocessing. This study presents a unified solution for simultaneous calculation of the super-equilibrium reactions and related reaction enthalpies in the gasification process. The solution is based on the Constrained Free Energy (CFE) method where equilibrium computation is extended with additional immaterial constraints for solving the local or partial constrained equilibrium instead of the global thermodynamic equilibrium.Methodology: First applications of the constrained thermodynamic equilibrium method in Gibbs energy minimization were the conservation of immaterial properties [2] and inclusion of reaction kinetics into the Gibbs'ian multicomponent models [3,4]. In the course of time the method has found new applications, ranging from modelling sorption in pulp suspensions to determining surface tension of liquid mixtures [5]. Quite recently CFE has been used to estimate the super-equilibria of alkali metals and sulphur in black liquor combustion [6]. Today constrained free energy method is seen as a versatile tool for various fields of application. In this study the CFE methodology is applied for describing the super-equilibrium occurring in biomass gasification. Light hydrocarbons, ammonia, tars and char tend to decompose if thermodynamic equilibrium calculation is performed for high temperatures, and thus constraints are needed for the modelling of their presence in the super-equilibrium conditions. This a computational study with all experimental data obtained from literature. The empirical model of super-equilibrium applied is from [1]. Thermodynamic data is from [7]. ChemSheet [8] is used as the modelling tool as it allows extending the thermodynamic system and thus enables the calculations of constrained free energy models.Results: In the present work different approaches for the modelling of global or local equilibrium of biomass gasification have been assessed. First (i) thermodynamic equilibrium without any constraints is computed and used as reference. Later additional constraints are introduced to system, such as amount of (ii) char, (iii) tars, (iv) ammonia. The light hydrocarbons are defined by (v) the amount of carbon and by (vi) amount of hydrogen in hydrocarbons. In addition constraints such as (vii) amount of double bonds in hydrocarbons or (viii) methane amount are evaluated. Finally a fully constrained system, where all species are defined according to [1] is reported. The super-equilibrium of major syngas components (CO, CO2, H2, H2O and CH4) can be predicted with the proposed constrained free energy method. Accuracy of the model increases when an additional constraint for hydrogen in hydrocarbons is defined. At the same time the partial equilibrium moves further from the global equilibrium. While the adapted constraints were successful in evaluating the super-equilibrium of major species, the respective predictions for minor hydrocarbon components (C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, C3H8, C6H6) were not as satisfying. The selection of modelled light hydrocarbon components seems to be vital, if more accuracy is required. In addition by defining all species with separate constraints, it is possible to increase the accuracy of results, but with the cost of decreasing the degrees of freedom of the thermodynamic system.Summary: Constrained free energy method was successfully applied for the calculation of the super-equilibrium of light hydrocarbons, ammonia, tars and char in biomass gasification. Gasification can be solved as restricted partial equilibrium with a single calculation step. Thus, there is no need for post-processing corrections for e.g. volume or enthalpy flows. For a reasonable accuracy of the simulation model, it is not necessary to define constraints for all reactions, but a set of more general constraints (e.g. carbon in hydrocarbons) remain sufficient. Distinct benefit of presented approach is that chemical reactions, gasification enthalpy and states of the system (such as volume) are estimated concurrently. This method is also resilient: the number of details describing constraints can vary from simpler experimental results and models to complicated mechanistic models. A promising application area for the presented methodology could be as part of large scale process simulation where detailed thermodynamic models can be implemented and effects in gasification chemistry could conduct changes in the entire process.

AB - Background: Biomass gasification can be seen as a viable option for generating electricity from biomass with high efficiency or for the production of liquid biofuels and chemicals. Gasification is a thermo-chemical conversion process that takes place at high temperature and reductive environment. For such conditions thermodynamic equilibrium is often assumed, but not reached in practice: during biomass gasification light hydrocarbons (e.g.: CH4, C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, C3H8, C6H6), ammonia, tars and char are also formed. These phenomena cannot usually be modelled with equilibrium assumptions. In order to increase the accuracy of gasification models, both empirical and mechanistic models are often applied alone or combined with thermodynamic equilibrium calculations [1]. This leads to a 'dual' approach where different parts of the process and reactions are modelled independently and results are merged in postprocessing. This study presents a unified solution for simultaneous calculation of the super-equilibrium reactions and related reaction enthalpies in the gasification process. The solution is based on the Constrained Free Energy (CFE) method where equilibrium computation is extended with additional immaterial constraints for solving the local or partial constrained equilibrium instead of the global thermodynamic equilibrium.Methodology: First applications of the constrained thermodynamic equilibrium method in Gibbs energy minimization were the conservation of immaterial properties [2] and inclusion of reaction kinetics into the Gibbs'ian multicomponent models [3,4]. In the course of time the method has found new applications, ranging from modelling sorption in pulp suspensions to determining surface tension of liquid mixtures [5]. Quite recently CFE has been used to estimate the super-equilibria of alkali metals and sulphur in black liquor combustion [6]. Today constrained free energy method is seen as a versatile tool for various fields of application. In this study the CFE methodology is applied for describing the super-equilibrium occurring in biomass gasification. Light hydrocarbons, ammonia, tars and char tend to decompose if thermodynamic equilibrium calculation is performed for high temperatures, and thus constraints are needed for the modelling of their presence in the super-equilibrium conditions. This a computational study with all experimental data obtained from literature. The empirical model of super-equilibrium applied is from [1]. Thermodynamic data is from [7]. ChemSheet [8] is used as the modelling tool as it allows extending the thermodynamic system and thus enables the calculations of constrained free energy models.Results: In the present work different approaches for the modelling of global or local equilibrium of biomass gasification have been assessed. First (i) thermodynamic equilibrium without any constraints is computed and used as reference. Later additional constraints are introduced to system, such as amount of (ii) char, (iii) tars, (iv) ammonia. The light hydrocarbons are defined by (v) the amount of carbon and by (vi) amount of hydrogen in hydrocarbons. In addition constraints such as (vii) amount of double bonds in hydrocarbons or (viii) methane amount are evaluated. Finally a fully constrained system, where all species are defined according to [1] is reported. The super-equilibrium of major syngas components (CO, CO2, H2, H2O and CH4) can be predicted with the proposed constrained free energy method. Accuracy of the model increases when an additional constraint for hydrogen in hydrocarbons is defined. At the same time the partial equilibrium moves further from the global equilibrium. While the adapted constraints were successful in evaluating the super-equilibrium of major species, the respective predictions for minor hydrocarbon components (C2H2, C2H4, C2H6, C3H8, C6H6) were not as satisfying. The selection of modelled light hydrocarbon components seems to be vital, if more accuracy is required. In addition by defining all species with separate constraints, it is possible to increase the accuracy of results, but with the cost of decreasing the degrees of freedom of the thermodynamic system.Summary: Constrained free energy method was successfully applied for the calculation of the super-equilibrium of light hydrocarbons, ammonia, tars and char in biomass gasification. Gasification can be solved as restricted partial equilibrium with a single calculation step. Thus, there is no need for post-processing corrections for e.g. volume or enthalpy flows. For a reasonable accuracy of the simulation model, it is not necessary to define constraints for all reactions, but a set of more general constraints (e.g. carbon in hydrocarbons) remain sufficient. Distinct benefit of presented approach is that chemical reactions, gasification enthalpy and states of the system (such as volume) are estimated concurrently. This method is also resilient: the number of details describing constraints can vary from simpler experimental results and models to complicated mechanistic models. A promising application area for the presented methodology could be as part of large scale process simulation where detailed thermodynamic models can be implemented and effects in gasification chemistry could conduct changes in the entire process.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84911472843&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Conference article in proceedings

AN - SCOPUS:84911472843

SP - 211

EP - 213

BT - Computational Molecular Science and Engineering Forum 2013 - Core Programming Area at the 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting

PB - American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE

ER -

Kangas P, Koukkari P, Hannula I. Modelling super-equilibrium in biomass gasification with the constrained gibbs energy method. In Computational Molecular Science and Engineering Forum 2013 - Core Programming Area at the 2013 AIChE Annual Meeting: Global Challenges for Engineering a Sustainable Future. American Institute of Chemical Engineers AIChE. 2013. p. 211-213