Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System

Task 2 Working Paper of the GoReNEST project

Torsti Loikkanen, Annele Eerola, Tiina Koljonen, Robert Van der Have, Nina Wessberg

Research output: Book/ReportReportProfessional

Abstract

This working paper is produced for the purposes of the GoReNEST project. The overall aim of the GoReNEST project is to present an analytical system transition framework as a potential tool for supporting the Nordic energy system transition, its governance and related policy-making. The MLP transition management approach was used as a starting point for the analytical framework that was developed in GoReNEST Task 1 (see Könnölä et al., 2008). In GoReNEST Task 2, recent and ongoing Nordic research was examined vis-à-vis the different elements, categories and topics of the system transition framework. This working paper summarizes the results of GoReNEST Task 2. The focus of this working paper is on Nordic research that is intended to support the governance of energy system transition. When assessing the potential of the MLP approach - and the analytical framework developed in GoReNEST Task 1 - it is important to know whether and how far the different elements and dimensions related to this approach have already been examined in Nordic energy research. For the purpose, (a) national level studies of Nordic countries, (b) studies carried out on Nordic level, and, (c) studies carried out with Nordic participation on European and international level, were examined in GoReNEST Task 2 with this aim. This working paper gives a first rough indicative overview of the contribution of these studies, paving the way for more extensive exercises in this respect. Six relevant, partly overlapping research approaches were identified in GoReNEST Task 2: 1) societal embedding of energy innovations, 2) consumer research in energy markets, 3) energy system modelling and scenarios, 4) energy foresight and technology assessment, 5) energy RDT program and policy program evaluations, and 6) innovation studies and energy related new governance research. Each category is briefly described in this working paper, followed by brief presentations of relevant example projects and positioning of their contribution in relevant boxes of the system transition framework (vertically by development levels: landscape, regime, niche, and governance; horizontally by time perspectives: present, short-term, medium-term, and long-term). GoReNEST Task 2 shows that Nordic research encompasses a number of interesting studies and projects in the six relevant areas of research approaches. In the light of the system transition framework, the contribution of these different studies and projects is also relevant for the governance of the energy system transition. Consequently, the existing research competencies in these areas are an important potential for the future research supporting the Nordic energy system transition, and hence it is worth building on these experiences and competencies in Nordic countries. The Nordic research is, however, scattered and fragmented among the six research areas, and the related aspects and dimensions of the systems transition framework. The overview also indicates relatively minor collaboration between relevant research communities, especially between energy system research and innovation system research. This may limit the effectiveness of these research communities in facing the multidisciplinary challenges of energy system transition. The MLP transition management approach and the comprehensive analytical framework of GoReNEST Task 1 offers, however, a potential common framework with the help of which relevant actors and actions can be mobilized around more effective joint-efforts that contribute to the transition towards sustainable energy systems. A systemic research agenda, considering the potential contribution of the various research approaches to the governance of energy system transition, is also needed.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationEspoo
PublisherVTT Technical Research Centre of Finland
Number of pages66
ISBN (Electronic)978-951-38-7481-0
Publication statusPublished - 2009
MoE publication typeNot Eligible

Publication series

NameVTT Working Papers
PublisherVTT
No.135
ISSN (Electronic)1459-7683

Fingerprint

Innovation

Keywords

  • Governance of Nordic energy transitions
  • research
  • approaches and methodologies of Nordic energy research
  • support to Nordic energy and climate policy-making

Cite this

Loikkanen, T., Eerola, A., Koljonen, T., Have, R. V. D., & Wessberg, N. (2009). Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System: Task 2 Working Paper of the GoReNEST project. Espoo: VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland. VTT Working Papers, No. 135
Loikkanen, Torsti ; Eerola, Annele ; Koljonen, Tiina ; Have, Robert Van der ; Wessberg, Nina. / Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System : Task 2 Working Paper of the GoReNEST project. Espoo : VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2009. 66 p. (VTT Working Papers; No. 135).
@book{2d7cfd2b73be4374ba1ca7fadfc20861,
title = "Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System: Task 2 Working Paper of the GoReNEST project",
abstract = "This working paper is produced for the purposes of the GoReNEST project. The overall aim of the GoReNEST project is to present an analytical system transition framework as a potential tool for supporting the Nordic energy system transition, its governance and related policy-making. The MLP transition management approach was used as a starting point for the analytical framework that was developed in GoReNEST Task 1 (see K{\"o}nn{\"o}l{\"a} et al., 2008). In GoReNEST Task 2, recent and ongoing Nordic research was examined vis-{\`a}-vis the different elements, categories and topics of the system transition framework. This working paper summarizes the results of GoReNEST Task 2. The focus of this working paper is on Nordic research that is intended to support the governance of energy system transition. When assessing the potential of the MLP approach - and the analytical framework developed in GoReNEST Task 1 - it is important to know whether and how far the different elements and dimensions related to this approach have already been examined in Nordic energy research. For the purpose, (a) national level studies of Nordic countries, (b) studies carried out on Nordic level, and, (c) studies carried out with Nordic participation on European and international level, were examined in GoReNEST Task 2 with this aim. This working paper gives a first rough indicative overview of the contribution of these studies, paving the way for more extensive exercises in this respect. Six relevant, partly overlapping research approaches were identified in GoReNEST Task 2: 1) societal embedding of energy innovations, 2) consumer research in energy markets, 3) energy system modelling and scenarios, 4) energy foresight and technology assessment, 5) energy RDT program and policy program evaluations, and 6) innovation studies and energy related new governance research. Each category is briefly described in this working paper, followed by brief presentations of relevant example projects and positioning of their contribution in relevant boxes of the system transition framework (vertically by development levels: landscape, regime, niche, and governance; horizontally by time perspectives: present, short-term, medium-term, and long-term). GoReNEST Task 2 shows that Nordic research encompasses a number of interesting studies and projects in the six relevant areas of research approaches. In the light of the system transition framework, the contribution of these different studies and projects is also relevant for the governance of the energy system transition. Consequently, the existing research competencies in these areas are an important potential for the future research supporting the Nordic energy system transition, and hence it is worth building on these experiences and competencies in Nordic countries. The Nordic research is, however, scattered and fragmented among the six research areas, and the related aspects and dimensions of the systems transition framework. The overview also indicates relatively minor collaboration between relevant research communities, especially between energy system research and innovation system research. This may limit the effectiveness of these research communities in facing the multidisciplinary challenges of energy system transition. The MLP transition management approach and the comprehensive analytical framework of GoReNEST Task 1 offers, however, a potential common framework with the help of which relevant actors and actions can be mobilized around more effective joint-efforts that contribute to the transition towards sustainable energy systems. A systemic research agenda, considering the potential contribution of the various research approaches to the governance of energy system transition, is also needed.",
keywords = "Governance of Nordic energy transitions, research, approaches and methodologies of Nordic energy research, support to Nordic energy and climate policy-making",
author = "Torsti Loikkanen and Annele Eerola and Tiina Koljonen and Have, {Robert Van der} and Nina Wessberg",
note = "Project code: 31368",
year = "2009",
language = "English",
series = "VTT Working Papers",
publisher = "VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland",
number = "135",
address = "Finland",

}

Loikkanen, T, Eerola, A, Koljonen, T, Have, RVD & Wessberg, N 2009, Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System: Task 2 Working Paper of the GoReNEST project. VTT Working Papers, no. 135, VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, Espoo.

Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System : Task 2 Working Paper of the GoReNEST project. / Loikkanen, Torsti; Eerola, Annele; Koljonen, Tiina; Have, Robert Van der; Wessberg, Nina.

Espoo : VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2009. 66 p. (VTT Working Papers; No. 135).

Research output: Book/ReportReportProfessional

TY - BOOK

T1 - Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System

T2 - Task 2 Working Paper of the GoReNEST project

AU - Loikkanen, Torsti

AU - Eerola, Annele

AU - Koljonen, Tiina

AU - Have, Robert Van der

AU - Wessberg, Nina

N1 - Project code: 31368

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - This working paper is produced for the purposes of the GoReNEST project. The overall aim of the GoReNEST project is to present an analytical system transition framework as a potential tool for supporting the Nordic energy system transition, its governance and related policy-making. The MLP transition management approach was used as a starting point for the analytical framework that was developed in GoReNEST Task 1 (see Könnölä et al., 2008). In GoReNEST Task 2, recent and ongoing Nordic research was examined vis-à-vis the different elements, categories and topics of the system transition framework. This working paper summarizes the results of GoReNEST Task 2. The focus of this working paper is on Nordic research that is intended to support the governance of energy system transition. When assessing the potential of the MLP approach - and the analytical framework developed in GoReNEST Task 1 - it is important to know whether and how far the different elements and dimensions related to this approach have already been examined in Nordic energy research. For the purpose, (a) national level studies of Nordic countries, (b) studies carried out on Nordic level, and, (c) studies carried out with Nordic participation on European and international level, were examined in GoReNEST Task 2 with this aim. This working paper gives a first rough indicative overview of the contribution of these studies, paving the way for more extensive exercises in this respect. Six relevant, partly overlapping research approaches were identified in GoReNEST Task 2: 1) societal embedding of energy innovations, 2) consumer research in energy markets, 3) energy system modelling and scenarios, 4) energy foresight and technology assessment, 5) energy RDT program and policy program evaluations, and 6) innovation studies and energy related new governance research. Each category is briefly described in this working paper, followed by brief presentations of relevant example projects and positioning of their contribution in relevant boxes of the system transition framework (vertically by development levels: landscape, regime, niche, and governance; horizontally by time perspectives: present, short-term, medium-term, and long-term). GoReNEST Task 2 shows that Nordic research encompasses a number of interesting studies and projects in the six relevant areas of research approaches. In the light of the system transition framework, the contribution of these different studies and projects is also relevant for the governance of the energy system transition. Consequently, the existing research competencies in these areas are an important potential for the future research supporting the Nordic energy system transition, and hence it is worth building on these experiences and competencies in Nordic countries. The Nordic research is, however, scattered and fragmented among the six research areas, and the related aspects and dimensions of the systems transition framework. The overview also indicates relatively minor collaboration between relevant research communities, especially between energy system research and innovation system research. This may limit the effectiveness of these research communities in facing the multidisciplinary challenges of energy system transition. The MLP transition management approach and the comprehensive analytical framework of GoReNEST Task 1 offers, however, a potential common framework with the help of which relevant actors and actions can be mobilized around more effective joint-efforts that contribute to the transition towards sustainable energy systems. A systemic research agenda, considering the potential contribution of the various research approaches to the governance of energy system transition, is also needed.

AB - This working paper is produced for the purposes of the GoReNEST project. The overall aim of the GoReNEST project is to present an analytical system transition framework as a potential tool for supporting the Nordic energy system transition, its governance and related policy-making. The MLP transition management approach was used as a starting point for the analytical framework that was developed in GoReNEST Task 1 (see Könnölä et al., 2008). In GoReNEST Task 2, recent and ongoing Nordic research was examined vis-à-vis the different elements, categories and topics of the system transition framework. This working paper summarizes the results of GoReNEST Task 2. The focus of this working paper is on Nordic research that is intended to support the governance of energy system transition. When assessing the potential of the MLP approach - and the analytical framework developed in GoReNEST Task 1 - it is important to know whether and how far the different elements and dimensions related to this approach have already been examined in Nordic energy research. For the purpose, (a) national level studies of Nordic countries, (b) studies carried out on Nordic level, and, (c) studies carried out with Nordic participation on European and international level, were examined in GoReNEST Task 2 with this aim. This working paper gives a first rough indicative overview of the contribution of these studies, paving the way for more extensive exercises in this respect. Six relevant, partly overlapping research approaches were identified in GoReNEST Task 2: 1) societal embedding of energy innovations, 2) consumer research in energy markets, 3) energy system modelling and scenarios, 4) energy foresight and technology assessment, 5) energy RDT program and policy program evaluations, and 6) innovation studies and energy related new governance research. Each category is briefly described in this working paper, followed by brief presentations of relevant example projects and positioning of their contribution in relevant boxes of the system transition framework (vertically by development levels: landscape, regime, niche, and governance; horizontally by time perspectives: present, short-term, medium-term, and long-term). GoReNEST Task 2 shows that Nordic research encompasses a number of interesting studies and projects in the six relevant areas of research approaches. In the light of the system transition framework, the contribution of these different studies and projects is also relevant for the governance of the energy system transition. Consequently, the existing research competencies in these areas are an important potential for the future research supporting the Nordic energy system transition, and hence it is worth building on these experiences and competencies in Nordic countries. The Nordic research is, however, scattered and fragmented among the six research areas, and the related aspects and dimensions of the systems transition framework. The overview also indicates relatively minor collaboration between relevant research communities, especially between energy system research and innovation system research. This may limit the effectiveness of these research communities in facing the multidisciplinary challenges of energy system transition. The MLP transition management approach and the comprehensive analytical framework of GoReNEST Task 1 offers, however, a potential common framework with the help of which relevant actors and actions can be mobilized around more effective joint-efforts that contribute to the transition towards sustainable energy systems. A systemic research agenda, considering the potential contribution of the various research approaches to the governance of energy system transition, is also needed.

KW - Governance of Nordic energy transitions

KW - research

KW - approaches and methodologies of Nordic energy research

KW - support to Nordic energy and climate policy-making

M3 - Report

T3 - VTT Working Papers

BT - Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System

PB - VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland

CY - Espoo

ER -

Loikkanen T, Eerola A, Koljonen T, Have RVD, Wessberg N. Nordic Energy Research within the Framework of Energy System: Task 2 Working Paper of the GoReNEST project. Espoo: VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2009. 66 p. (VTT Working Papers; No. 135).