Old wine in new bottles and new wine in old bottles

Antti Oulasvirta, Pertti Saariluoma, Rebekah Rousi, Jaana Leikas

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleProfessional

Abstract

Underlying the recent surge in interest in user experience may be the realization that consumers have increasing power over the fate of information technology. Taken literally, user experience concerns the subjective first-person feeling (hence "experience") arising when technology is being used for something (hence "user"). This is the interpretation assumed in the article. The authors claim that the failure to produce a reliable scientific body of knowledge about UX is partly due to falsely treating it as a new topic, as if nothing has ever been said about it before. Although it is inaccurate to claim that UX has been entirely ignorant of psychology, treating UX as if it was something truly novel is one of the biggest impediments to scientific progress in this field, and it is manifest in the lack of reliable methods and actionable theories. We need to reformulate our understanding of UX in a way that connects it to areas of research that deal with human experience.
Original languageEnglish
Article number732
JournalUX Magazine
Issue numberSeptember
Publication statusPublished - 2011
MoE publication typeD1 Article in a trade journal

Fingerprint

Wine
Bottles
Information technology

Cite this

Oulasvirta, A., Saariluoma, P., Rousi, R., & Leikas, J. (2011). Old wine in new bottles and new wine in old bottles. UX Magazine, (September), [732].
Oulasvirta, Antti ; Saariluoma, Pertti ; Rousi, Rebekah ; Leikas, Jaana. / Old wine in new bottles and new wine in old bottles. In: UX Magazine. 2011 ; No. September.
@article{d45c3081edf44539a2426334d88a4999,
title = "Old wine in new bottles and new wine in old bottles",
abstract = "Underlying the recent surge in interest in user experience may be the realization that consumers have increasing power over the fate of information technology. Taken literally, user experience concerns the subjective first-person feeling (hence {"}experience{"}) arising when technology is being used for something (hence {"}user{"}). This is the interpretation assumed in the article. The authors claim that the failure to produce a reliable scientific body of knowledge about UX is partly due to falsely treating it as a new topic, as if nothing has ever been said about it before. Although it is inaccurate to claim that UX has been entirely ignorant of psychology, treating UX as if it was something truly novel is one of the biggest impediments to scientific progress in this field, and it is manifest in the lack of reliable methods and actionable theories. We need to reformulate our understanding of UX in a way that connects it to areas of research that deal with human experience.",
author = "Antti Oulasvirta and Pertti Saariluoma and Rebekah Rousi and Jaana Leikas",
note = "Project code: 39972",
year = "2011",
language = "English",
journal = "UX Magazine",
issn = "2168-5681",
publisher = "UX Magazine",
number = "September",

}

Oulasvirta, A, Saariluoma, P, Rousi, R & Leikas, J 2011, 'Old wine in new bottles and new wine in old bottles', UX Magazine, no. September, 732.

Old wine in new bottles and new wine in old bottles. / Oulasvirta, Antti; Saariluoma, Pertti; Rousi, Rebekah; Leikas, Jaana.

In: UX Magazine, No. September, 732, 2011.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleProfessional

TY - JOUR

T1 - Old wine in new bottles and new wine in old bottles

AU - Oulasvirta, Antti

AU - Saariluoma, Pertti

AU - Rousi, Rebekah

AU - Leikas, Jaana

N1 - Project code: 39972

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - Underlying the recent surge in interest in user experience may be the realization that consumers have increasing power over the fate of information technology. Taken literally, user experience concerns the subjective first-person feeling (hence "experience") arising when technology is being used for something (hence "user"). This is the interpretation assumed in the article. The authors claim that the failure to produce a reliable scientific body of knowledge about UX is partly due to falsely treating it as a new topic, as if nothing has ever been said about it before. Although it is inaccurate to claim that UX has been entirely ignorant of psychology, treating UX as if it was something truly novel is one of the biggest impediments to scientific progress in this field, and it is manifest in the lack of reliable methods and actionable theories. We need to reformulate our understanding of UX in a way that connects it to areas of research that deal with human experience.

AB - Underlying the recent surge in interest in user experience may be the realization that consumers have increasing power over the fate of information technology. Taken literally, user experience concerns the subjective first-person feeling (hence "experience") arising when technology is being used for something (hence "user"). This is the interpretation assumed in the article. The authors claim that the failure to produce a reliable scientific body of knowledge about UX is partly due to falsely treating it as a new topic, as if nothing has ever been said about it before. Although it is inaccurate to claim that UX has been entirely ignorant of psychology, treating UX as if it was something truly novel is one of the biggest impediments to scientific progress in this field, and it is manifest in the lack of reliable methods and actionable theories. We need to reformulate our understanding of UX in a way that connects it to areas of research that deal with human experience.

M3 - Article

JO - UX Magazine

JF - UX Magazine

SN - 2168-5681

IS - September

M1 - 732

ER -

Oulasvirta A, Saariluoma P, Rousi R, Leikas J. Old wine in new bottles and new wine in old bottles. UX Magazine. 2011;(September). 732.