Recent advances on containment iodine chemistry

S. Dickinson (Corresponding Author), F. Andreo, Teemu Kärkelä, J. Ball, L. Bosland, L. Cantrel, F. Funke, N. Girault, J. Holm, S. Guilbert, L. E. Herranz, C. Housiadas, G. Ducros, C. Mun, J.-C. Sabroux, G. Weber

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    12 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    The 5th FWP EURSAFE Project highlighted iodine chemistry in the containment as one of the issues requiring further research in order to reduce source term uncertainties. Consequently, a series of studies was launched in the 6th FWP SARNET Project aimed at improving the predictability of iodine behaviour during severe accidents via a better understanding of the complex chemical phenomena in the containment. In particular, SARNET has striven to foster common interpretation of integral and separate effect test data, production of new or improved models where necessary, and compilation of the existing knowledge of the subject. The work has been based on a substantial amount of experimental information made available from bench-scale projects (PARIS and EPICUR), via intermediate-scale tests (CAIMAN) to large-scale facilities (SISYPHE, THAI and PHEBUS-FP). In the experimental field, particular attention has been paid to two specific issues: the effects of radiation on both aqueous and gaseous iodine chemistry, and the mass transfer of iodine between aqueous and gaseous phases. Comparisons between calculations and results of the EPICUR and CAIMAN experiments suggest that the aqueous phase chemistry is reasonably well understood, although there are still some areas of uncertainty. Interpretation of integral experiments, like PHEBUS-FPT2, indicated that radiation-induced conversion of molecular iodine into particulate species (IxOy) could be responsible for the gaseous iodine depletion observed in the long-term. However, the results of much simpler, small-scale experiments have shown that further improvements in understanding and modelling are still needed. Mass transfer modelling has been extended to cover evaporating sump conditions based on SISYPHE data; however, application of this model to the larger scale THAI experiments seems not to be straightforward. In addition to these two major issues, some specific studies have been carried out concerning the potential effect of passive autocatalytic hydrogen recombiners on iodine volatility. The RECI analytical experiments have shown that metal iodides (namely CsI and CdI2) are not stable and yield gaseous iodine when heated, in a humid atmosphere, at temperatures representative of recombiner operation. Another important undertaking successfully carried out has been the compilation of an Iodine Data Book, which provides a critical review of the experimental data and modelling approaches that have been used in the development of iodine source term methodologies. This should assist in a proper use of such models, and inform their future development.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)128-135
    Number of pages8
    JournalProgress in Nuclear Energy
    Volume52
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2010
    MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

    Fingerprint

    iodine
    containment
    Iodine
    experiment
    Experiments
    mass transfer
    Mass transfer
    chemical phenomena
    modeling
    Radiation
    iodide
    accident
    Accidents
    hydrogen
    Hydrogen
    methodology
    atmosphere
    metal

    Keywords

    • Containment
    • Iodine Chemistry
    • LWR Severe Accident

    Cite this

    Dickinson, S., Andreo, F., Kärkelä, T., Ball, J., Bosland, L., Cantrel, L., ... Weber, G. (2010). Recent advances on containment iodine chemistry. Progress in Nuclear Energy, 52(1), 128-135. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pnucene.2009.09.009
    Dickinson, S. ; Andreo, F. ; Kärkelä, Teemu ; Ball, J. ; Bosland, L. ; Cantrel, L. ; Funke, F. ; Girault, N. ; Holm, J. ; Guilbert, S. ; Herranz, L. E. ; Housiadas, C. ; Ducros, G. ; Mun, C. ; Sabroux, J.-C. ; Weber, G. / Recent advances on containment iodine chemistry. In: Progress in Nuclear Energy. 2010 ; Vol. 52, No. 1. pp. 128-135.
    @article{6e7ab82d8d52423fbf8860731164c607,
    title = "Recent advances on containment iodine chemistry",
    abstract = "The 5th FWP EURSAFE Project highlighted iodine chemistry in the containment as one of the issues requiring further research in order to reduce source term uncertainties. Consequently, a series of studies was launched in the 6th FWP SARNET Project aimed at improving the predictability of iodine behaviour during severe accidents via a better understanding of the complex chemical phenomena in the containment. In particular, SARNET has striven to foster common interpretation of integral and separate effect test data, production of new or improved models where necessary, and compilation of the existing knowledge of the subject. The work has been based on a substantial amount of experimental information made available from bench-scale projects (PARIS and EPICUR), via intermediate-scale tests (CAIMAN) to large-scale facilities (SISYPHE, THAI and PHEBUS-FP). In the experimental field, particular attention has been paid to two specific issues: the effects of radiation on both aqueous and gaseous iodine chemistry, and the mass transfer of iodine between aqueous and gaseous phases. Comparisons between calculations and results of the EPICUR and CAIMAN experiments suggest that the aqueous phase chemistry is reasonably well understood, although there are still some areas of uncertainty. Interpretation of integral experiments, like PHEBUS-FPT2, indicated that radiation-induced conversion of molecular iodine into particulate species (IxOy) could be responsible for the gaseous iodine depletion observed in the long-term. However, the results of much simpler, small-scale experiments have shown that further improvements in understanding and modelling are still needed. Mass transfer modelling has been extended to cover evaporating sump conditions based on SISYPHE data; however, application of this model to the larger scale THAI experiments seems not to be straightforward. In addition to these two major issues, some specific studies have been carried out concerning the potential effect of passive autocatalytic hydrogen recombiners on iodine volatility. The RECI analytical experiments have shown that metal iodides (namely CsI and CdI2) are not stable and yield gaseous iodine when heated, in a humid atmosphere, at temperatures representative of recombiner operation. Another important undertaking successfully carried out has been the compilation of an Iodine Data Book, which provides a critical review of the experimental data and modelling approaches that have been used in the development of iodine source term methodologies. This should assist in a proper use of such models, and inform their future development.",
    keywords = "Containment, Iodine Chemistry, LWR Severe Accident",
    author = "S. Dickinson and F. Andreo and Teemu K{\"a}rkel{\"a} and J. Ball and L. Bosland and L. Cantrel and F. Funke and N. Girault and J. Holm and S. Guilbert and Herranz, {L. E.} and C. Housiadas and G. Ducros and C. Mun and J.-C. Sabroux and G. Weber",
    year = "2010",
    doi = "10.1016/j.pnucene.2009.09.009",
    language = "English",
    volume = "52",
    pages = "128--135",
    journal = "Progress in Nuclear Energy",
    issn = "0149-1970",
    publisher = "Elsevier",
    number = "1",

    }

    Dickinson, S, Andreo, F, Kärkelä, T, Ball, J, Bosland, L, Cantrel, L, Funke, F, Girault, N, Holm, J, Guilbert, S, Herranz, LE, Housiadas, C, Ducros, G, Mun, C, Sabroux, J-C & Weber, G 2010, 'Recent advances on containment iodine chemistry', Progress in Nuclear Energy, vol. 52, no. 1, pp. 128-135. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pnucene.2009.09.009

    Recent advances on containment iodine chemistry. / Dickinson, S. (Corresponding Author); Andreo, F.; Kärkelä, Teemu; Ball, J.; Bosland, L.; Cantrel, L.; Funke, F.; Girault, N.; Holm, J.; Guilbert, S.; Herranz, L. E.; Housiadas, C.; Ducros, G.; Mun, C.; Sabroux, J.-C.; Weber, G.

    In: Progress in Nuclear Energy, Vol. 52, No. 1, 2010, p. 128-135.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Recent advances on containment iodine chemistry

    AU - Dickinson, S.

    AU - Andreo, F.

    AU - Kärkelä, Teemu

    AU - Ball, J.

    AU - Bosland, L.

    AU - Cantrel, L.

    AU - Funke, F.

    AU - Girault, N.

    AU - Holm, J.

    AU - Guilbert, S.

    AU - Herranz, L. E.

    AU - Housiadas, C.

    AU - Ducros, G.

    AU - Mun, C.

    AU - Sabroux, J.-C.

    AU - Weber, G.

    PY - 2010

    Y1 - 2010

    N2 - The 5th FWP EURSAFE Project highlighted iodine chemistry in the containment as one of the issues requiring further research in order to reduce source term uncertainties. Consequently, a series of studies was launched in the 6th FWP SARNET Project aimed at improving the predictability of iodine behaviour during severe accidents via a better understanding of the complex chemical phenomena in the containment. In particular, SARNET has striven to foster common interpretation of integral and separate effect test data, production of new or improved models where necessary, and compilation of the existing knowledge of the subject. The work has been based on a substantial amount of experimental information made available from bench-scale projects (PARIS and EPICUR), via intermediate-scale tests (CAIMAN) to large-scale facilities (SISYPHE, THAI and PHEBUS-FP). In the experimental field, particular attention has been paid to two specific issues: the effects of radiation on both aqueous and gaseous iodine chemistry, and the mass transfer of iodine between aqueous and gaseous phases. Comparisons between calculations and results of the EPICUR and CAIMAN experiments suggest that the aqueous phase chemistry is reasonably well understood, although there are still some areas of uncertainty. Interpretation of integral experiments, like PHEBUS-FPT2, indicated that radiation-induced conversion of molecular iodine into particulate species (IxOy) could be responsible for the gaseous iodine depletion observed in the long-term. However, the results of much simpler, small-scale experiments have shown that further improvements in understanding and modelling are still needed. Mass transfer modelling has been extended to cover evaporating sump conditions based on SISYPHE data; however, application of this model to the larger scale THAI experiments seems not to be straightforward. In addition to these two major issues, some specific studies have been carried out concerning the potential effect of passive autocatalytic hydrogen recombiners on iodine volatility. The RECI analytical experiments have shown that metal iodides (namely CsI and CdI2) are not stable and yield gaseous iodine when heated, in a humid atmosphere, at temperatures representative of recombiner operation. Another important undertaking successfully carried out has been the compilation of an Iodine Data Book, which provides a critical review of the experimental data and modelling approaches that have been used in the development of iodine source term methodologies. This should assist in a proper use of such models, and inform their future development.

    AB - The 5th FWP EURSAFE Project highlighted iodine chemistry in the containment as one of the issues requiring further research in order to reduce source term uncertainties. Consequently, a series of studies was launched in the 6th FWP SARNET Project aimed at improving the predictability of iodine behaviour during severe accidents via a better understanding of the complex chemical phenomena in the containment. In particular, SARNET has striven to foster common interpretation of integral and separate effect test data, production of new or improved models where necessary, and compilation of the existing knowledge of the subject. The work has been based on a substantial amount of experimental information made available from bench-scale projects (PARIS and EPICUR), via intermediate-scale tests (CAIMAN) to large-scale facilities (SISYPHE, THAI and PHEBUS-FP). In the experimental field, particular attention has been paid to two specific issues: the effects of radiation on both aqueous and gaseous iodine chemistry, and the mass transfer of iodine between aqueous and gaseous phases. Comparisons between calculations and results of the EPICUR and CAIMAN experiments suggest that the aqueous phase chemistry is reasonably well understood, although there are still some areas of uncertainty. Interpretation of integral experiments, like PHEBUS-FPT2, indicated that radiation-induced conversion of molecular iodine into particulate species (IxOy) could be responsible for the gaseous iodine depletion observed in the long-term. However, the results of much simpler, small-scale experiments have shown that further improvements in understanding and modelling are still needed. Mass transfer modelling has been extended to cover evaporating sump conditions based on SISYPHE data; however, application of this model to the larger scale THAI experiments seems not to be straightforward. In addition to these two major issues, some specific studies have been carried out concerning the potential effect of passive autocatalytic hydrogen recombiners on iodine volatility. The RECI analytical experiments have shown that metal iodides (namely CsI and CdI2) are not stable and yield gaseous iodine when heated, in a humid atmosphere, at temperatures representative of recombiner operation. Another important undertaking successfully carried out has been the compilation of an Iodine Data Book, which provides a critical review of the experimental data and modelling approaches that have been used in the development of iodine source term methodologies. This should assist in a proper use of such models, and inform their future development.

    KW - Containment

    KW - Iodine Chemistry

    KW - LWR Severe Accident

    U2 - 10.1016/j.pnucene.2009.09.009

    DO - 10.1016/j.pnucene.2009.09.009

    M3 - Article

    VL - 52

    SP - 128

    EP - 135

    JO - Progress in Nuclear Energy

    JF - Progress in Nuclear Energy

    SN - 0149-1970

    IS - 1

    ER -