Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure

Matti Pajari

Research output: Book/ReportReportProfessional

Abstract

Eurocode 2 presents a design method for the shear resistance, which according to harmonized standard EN 1168 is to be used for the web shear failure of prestressed hollow core slabs. To check the validity of the method, 49 shear tests on hollow core slabs with thickness 200-500 mm have been analysed. The Eurocode 2 method overestimated the mean shear resistance of all tested slab types. For 200 mm slabs and slabs with flat webs the overestimation was tens of percent. When the characteristic values of experimental and theoretical resistance were compared, the fit was better but there was still a considerable overestimation for 200 mm slabs and for the slabs with flat webs. On the other hand, the Eurocode 2 method was (over)conservative for 265 mm and 320 mm slabs with circular voids. The Eurocode 2 method ignores the shear stresses due to the transfer of the prestressing force. When these stresses were taken into account applying Yang's method, the accuracy for 265 mm and 320 mm slabs with circular voids was the same as when using the Eurocode 2 method but much better for the other slabs. Based on the results of the comparison, Yang's method for design against web shear failure should replace the present method in Eurocode 2. It is not acceptable, however, to adopt a design method which overestimates the characteristic resistance of some product type by 10% as Yang's method seems to do. Whether this is really the case, is still an open question because the number of tests on the problematic slabs was small. Furthermore, due to the nature of the type approval tests, some test specimens may have been weaker than the slabs typical of normal production. The Eurocode 2 method should not be used for slabs with flat webs without a reduction factor, and its applicability to other slab types should always be verified either numerically of experimentally before it is used.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationEspoo
PublisherVTT Technical Research Centre of Finland
Number of pages68
ISBN (Electronic)951-38-6552-5
ISBN (Print)951-38-6709-9
Publication statusPublished - 2005
MoE publication typeNot Eligible

Publication series

NameVTT Tiedotteita - Research Notes
PublisherVTT
No.2292
ISSN (Print)1235-0605
ISSN (Electronic)1455-0865

Fingerprint

Prestressing
Shear stress
Web Design

Keywords

  • hollow core slab
  • prestress
  • shear
  • test
  • resistance
  • concrete
  • precast
  • structure
  • design
  • Eurocode

Cite this

Pajari, M. (2005). Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure. Espoo: VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland. VTT Tiedotteita - Meddelanden - Research Notes, No. 2292
Pajari, Matti. / Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure. Espoo : VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2005. 68 p. (VTT Tiedotteita - Meddelanden - Research Notes; No. 2292).
@book{f89ba3f7e2544cbcba4a18106373a6c0,
title = "Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure",
abstract = "Eurocode 2 presents a design method for the shear resistance, which according to harmonized standard EN 1168 is to be used for the web shear failure of prestressed hollow core slabs. To check the validity of the method, 49 shear tests on hollow core slabs with thickness 200-500 mm have been analysed. The Eurocode 2 method overestimated the mean shear resistance of all tested slab types. For 200 mm slabs and slabs with flat webs the overestimation was tens of percent. When the characteristic values of experimental and theoretical resistance were compared, the fit was better but there was still a considerable overestimation for 200 mm slabs and for the slabs with flat webs. On the other hand, the Eurocode 2 method was (over)conservative for 265 mm and 320 mm slabs with circular voids. The Eurocode 2 method ignores the shear stresses due to the transfer of the prestressing force. When these stresses were taken into account applying Yang's method, the accuracy for 265 mm and 320 mm slabs with circular voids was the same as when using the Eurocode 2 method but much better for the other slabs. Based on the results of the comparison, Yang's method for design against web shear failure should replace the present method in Eurocode 2. It is not acceptable, however, to adopt a design method which overestimates the characteristic resistance of some product type by 10{\%} as Yang's method seems to do. Whether this is really the case, is still an open question because the number of tests on the problematic slabs was small. Furthermore, due to the nature of the type approval tests, some test specimens may have been weaker than the slabs typical of normal production. The Eurocode 2 method should not be used for slabs with flat webs without a reduction factor, and its applicability to other slab types should always be verified either numerically of experimentally before it is used.",
keywords = "hollow core slab, prestress, shear, test, resistance, concrete, precast, structure, design, Eurocode",
author = "Matti Pajari",
note = "Project code: R4SU00547",
year = "2005",
language = "English",
isbn = "951-38-6709-9",
series = "VTT Tiedotteita - Research Notes",
publisher = "VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland",
number = "2292",
address = "Finland",

}

Pajari, M 2005, Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure. VTT Tiedotteita - Meddelanden - Research Notes, no. 2292, VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, Espoo.

Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure. / Pajari, Matti.

Espoo : VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2005. 68 p. (VTT Tiedotteita - Meddelanden - Research Notes; No. 2292).

Research output: Book/ReportReportProfessional

TY - BOOK

T1 - Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure

AU - Pajari, Matti

N1 - Project code: R4SU00547

PY - 2005

Y1 - 2005

N2 - Eurocode 2 presents a design method for the shear resistance, which according to harmonized standard EN 1168 is to be used for the web shear failure of prestressed hollow core slabs. To check the validity of the method, 49 shear tests on hollow core slabs with thickness 200-500 mm have been analysed. The Eurocode 2 method overestimated the mean shear resistance of all tested slab types. For 200 mm slabs and slabs with flat webs the overestimation was tens of percent. When the characteristic values of experimental and theoretical resistance were compared, the fit was better but there was still a considerable overestimation for 200 mm slabs and for the slabs with flat webs. On the other hand, the Eurocode 2 method was (over)conservative for 265 mm and 320 mm slabs with circular voids. The Eurocode 2 method ignores the shear stresses due to the transfer of the prestressing force. When these stresses were taken into account applying Yang's method, the accuracy for 265 mm and 320 mm slabs with circular voids was the same as when using the Eurocode 2 method but much better for the other slabs. Based on the results of the comparison, Yang's method for design against web shear failure should replace the present method in Eurocode 2. It is not acceptable, however, to adopt a design method which overestimates the characteristic resistance of some product type by 10% as Yang's method seems to do. Whether this is really the case, is still an open question because the number of tests on the problematic slabs was small. Furthermore, due to the nature of the type approval tests, some test specimens may have been weaker than the slabs typical of normal production. The Eurocode 2 method should not be used for slabs with flat webs without a reduction factor, and its applicability to other slab types should always be verified either numerically of experimentally before it is used.

AB - Eurocode 2 presents a design method for the shear resistance, which according to harmonized standard EN 1168 is to be used for the web shear failure of prestressed hollow core slabs. To check the validity of the method, 49 shear tests on hollow core slabs with thickness 200-500 mm have been analysed. The Eurocode 2 method overestimated the mean shear resistance of all tested slab types. For 200 mm slabs and slabs with flat webs the overestimation was tens of percent. When the characteristic values of experimental and theoretical resistance were compared, the fit was better but there was still a considerable overestimation for 200 mm slabs and for the slabs with flat webs. On the other hand, the Eurocode 2 method was (over)conservative for 265 mm and 320 mm slabs with circular voids. The Eurocode 2 method ignores the shear stresses due to the transfer of the prestressing force. When these stresses were taken into account applying Yang's method, the accuracy for 265 mm and 320 mm slabs with circular voids was the same as when using the Eurocode 2 method but much better for the other slabs. Based on the results of the comparison, Yang's method for design against web shear failure should replace the present method in Eurocode 2. It is not acceptable, however, to adopt a design method which overestimates the characteristic resistance of some product type by 10% as Yang's method seems to do. Whether this is really the case, is still an open question because the number of tests on the problematic slabs was small. Furthermore, due to the nature of the type approval tests, some test specimens may have been weaker than the slabs typical of normal production. The Eurocode 2 method should not be used for slabs with flat webs without a reduction factor, and its applicability to other slab types should always be verified either numerically of experimentally before it is used.

KW - hollow core slab

KW - prestress

KW - shear

KW - test

KW - resistance

KW - concrete

KW - precast

KW - structure

KW - design

KW - Eurocode

M3 - Report

SN - 951-38-6709-9

T3 - VTT Tiedotteita - Research Notes

BT - Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure

PB - VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland

CY - Espoo

ER -

Pajari M. Resistance of prestressed hollow core slabs against web shear failure. Espoo: VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, 2005. 68 p. (VTT Tiedotteita - Meddelanden - Research Notes; No. 2292).