Serpent/SCF pin-level multiphysics solutions for the VERA Fuel Assembly benchmark

Diego Ferraro (Corresponding Author), Manuel Garcia, Uwe Imke, Ville Valtavirta, Jaakko Leppänen, Victor Sanchez-Espinoza

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    6 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Continuous improvement in nuclear industry safety standards and reactor designers’ and operators’ commercial goals represent a push for the development of highly accurate methodologies in reactor physics. Those methodologies are usually oriented to improve the prediction capabilities of specific reactors’ parameters under steady state and transient scenarios by the use of coupled state-of-the-art calculation codes. As a result, an important effort to develop highly accurate multiphysics approaches for nuclear reactor analysis is being held by diverse organizations and stakeholders around the world. Under this framework, the European Research and Innovation project McSAFE is a coordinated effort started in September 2017 with the objective of moving Monte Carlo (MC) stand-alone and coupled solution methodologies to become valuable tools for industry like applications for LWRs of generations II and III. As part of this project several developments in coupling strategies for transient and steady-state calculations are being developed, implemented and tested. Such capabilities assessment, together with the imperative verification and validation process are carried out inside McSAFE in a graded approach by the detailed comparison with high-quality benchmarks. As part of this approach, this work presents the main results obtained for the Fuel Assembly (FA) coupled Neutronic-Thermalhydraulic VERA Benchmark (namely VERA problem #6) proposed by the CASL consortium. For this purpose a pin-by-pin coupling scheme using the Serpent 2 MC code (developed by VTT, Finland) and the subchannel code SUBCHANFLOW (developed by KIT, Germany) was developed. Results are obtained and compared with diverse available published data from several similar high-fidelity calculation projects, both in terms of integral parameters and detailed axial profiles inside the FA at pin or coolant subchannel level. In addition, main additional key aspects of the problem are also presented and discussed. The results obtained and presented with the proposed approach show a very good agreement with available results from several similar high-fidelity projects, which encourages to continue to more complex problems and provides relevant insights for further developments and implementations.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)102-114
    Number of pages13
    JournalAnnals of Nuclear Energy
    Volume128
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 9 Jan 2019
    MoE publication typeNot Eligible

    Fingerprint

    Nuclear industry
    Nuclear reactors
    Coolants
    Physics
    Innovation
    Industry

    Keywords

    • High-fidelity multiphysics
    • Monte Carlo
    • Serpent 2
    • SUBCHANFLOW
    • VERA benchmark

    Cite this

    Ferraro, Diego ; Garcia, Manuel ; Imke, Uwe ; Valtavirta, Ville ; Leppänen, Jaakko ; Sanchez-Espinoza, Victor. / Serpent/SCF pin-level multiphysics solutions for the VERA Fuel Assembly benchmark. In: Annals of Nuclear Energy. 2019 ; Vol. 128. pp. 102-114.
    @article{45de307c691945c7a4b8fea08b0ebb48,
    title = "Serpent/SCF pin-level multiphysics solutions for the VERA Fuel Assembly benchmark",
    abstract = "Continuous improvement in nuclear industry safety standards and reactor designers’ and operators’ commercial goals represent a push for the development of highly accurate methodologies in reactor physics. Those methodologies are usually oriented to improve the prediction capabilities of specific reactors’ parameters under steady state and transient scenarios by the use of coupled state-of-the-art calculation codes. As a result, an important effort to develop highly accurate multiphysics approaches for nuclear reactor analysis is being held by diverse organizations and stakeholders around the world. Under this framework, the European Research and Innovation project McSAFE is a coordinated effort started in September 2017 with the objective of moving Monte Carlo (MC) stand-alone and coupled solution methodologies to become valuable tools for industry like applications for LWRs of generations II and III. As part of this project several developments in coupling strategies for transient and steady-state calculations are being developed, implemented and tested. Such capabilities assessment, together with the imperative verification and validation process are carried out inside McSAFE in a graded approach by the detailed comparison with high-quality benchmarks. As part of this approach, this work presents the main results obtained for the Fuel Assembly (FA) coupled Neutronic-Thermalhydraulic VERA Benchmark (namely VERA problem #6) proposed by the CASL consortium. For this purpose a pin-by-pin coupling scheme using the Serpent 2 MC code (developed by VTT, Finland) and the subchannel code SUBCHANFLOW (developed by KIT, Germany) was developed. Results are obtained and compared with diverse available published data from several similar high-fidelity calculation projects, both in terms of integral parameters and detailed axial profiles inside the FA at pin or coolant subchannel level. In addition, main additional key aspects of the problem are also presented and discussed. The results obtained and presented with the proposed approach show a very good agreement with available results from several similar high-fidelity projects, which encourages to continue to more complex problems and provides relevant insights for further developments and implementations.",
    keywords = "High-fidelity multiphysics, Monte Carlo, Serpent 2, SUBCHANFLOW, VERA benchmark",
    author = "Diego Ferraro and Manuel Garcia and Uwe Imke and Ville Valtavirta and Jaakko Lepp{\"a}nen and Victor Sanchez-Espinoza",
    year = "2019",
    month = "1",
    day = "9",
    doi = "10.1016/j.anucene.2018.12.047",
    language = "English",
    volume = "128",
    pages = "102--114",
    journal = "Annals of Nuclear Energy",
    issn = "0306-4549",
    publisher = "Elsevier",

    }

    Serpent/SCF pin-level multiphysics solutions for the VERA Fuel Assembly benchmark. / Ferraro, Diego (Corresponding Author); Garcia, Manuel; Imke, Uwe; Valtavirta, Ville; Leppänen, Jaakko; Sanchez-Espinoza, Victor.

    In: Annals of Nuclear Energy, Vol. 128, 09.01.2019, p. 102-114.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Serpent/SCF pin-level multiphysics solutions for the VERA Fuel Assembly benchmark

    AU - Ferraro, Diego

    AU - Garcia, Manuel

    AU - Imke, Uwe

    AU - Valtavirta, Ville

    AU - Leppänen, Jaakko

    AU - Sanchez-Espinoza, Victor

    PY - 2019/1/9

    Y1 - 2019/1/9

    N2 - Continuous improvement in nuclear industry safety standards and reactor designers’ and operators’ commercial goals represent a push for the development of highly accurate methodologies in reactor physics. Those methodologies are usually oriented to improve the prediction capabilities of specific reactors’ parameters under steady state and transient scenarios by the use of coupled state-of-the-art calculation codes. As a result, an important effort to develop highly accurate multiphysics approaches for nuclear reactor analysis is being held by diverse organizations and stakeholders around the world. Under this framework, the European Research and Innovation project McSAFE is a coordinated effort started in September 2017 with the objective of moving Monte Carlo (MC) stand-alone and coupled solution methodologies to become valuable tools for industry like applications for LWRs of generations II and III. As part of this project several developments in coupling strategies for transient and steady-state calculations are being developed, implemented and tested. Such capabilities assessment, together with the imperative verification and validation process are carried out inside McSAFE in a graded approach by the detailed comparison with high-quality benchmarks. As part of this approach, this work presents the main results obtained for the Fuel Assembly (FA) coupled Neutronic-Thermalhydraulic VERA Benchmark (namely VERA problem #6) proposed by the CASL consortium. For this purpose a pin-by-pin coupling scheme using the Serpent 2 MC code (developed by VTT, Finland) and the subchannel code SUBCHANFLOW (developed by KIT, Germany) was developed. Results are obtained and compared with diverse available published data from several similar high-fidelity calculation projects, both in terms of integral parameters and detailed axial profiles inside the FA at pin or coolant subchannel level. In addition, main additional key aspects of the problem are also presented and discussed. The results obtained and presented with the proposed approach show a very good agreement with available results from several similar high-fidelity projects, which encourages to continue to more complex problems and provides relevant insights for further developments and implementations.

    AB - Continuous improvement in nuclear industry safety standards and reactor designers’ and operators’ commercial goals represent a push for the development of highly accurate methodologies in reactor physics. Those methodologies are usually oriented to improve the prediction capabilities of specific reactors’ parameters under steady state and transient scenarios by the use of coupled state-of-the-art calculation codes. As a result, an important effort to develop highly accurate multiphysics approaches for nuclear reactor analysis is being held by diverse organizations and stakeholders around the world. Under this framework, the European Research and Innovation project McSAFE is a coordinated effort started in September 2017 with the objective of moving Monte Carlo (MC) stand-alone and coupled solution methodologies to become valuable tools for industry like applications for LWRs of generations II and III. As part of this project several developments in coupling strategies for transient and steady-state calculations are being developed, implemented and tested. Such capabilities assessment, together with the imperative verification and validation process are carried out inside McSAFE in a graded approach by the detailed comparison with high-quality benchmarks. As part of this approach, this work presents the main results obtained for the Fuel Assembly (FA) coupled Neutronic-Thermalhydraulic VERA Benchmark (namely VERA problem #6) proposed by the CASL consortium. For this purpose a pin-by-pin coupling scheme using the Serpent 2 MC code (developed by VTT, Finland) and the subchannel code SUBCHANFLOW (developed by KIT, Germany) was developed. Results are obtained and compared with diverse available published data from several similar high-fidelity calculation projects, both in terms of integral parameters and detailed axial profiles inside the FA at pin or coolant subchannel level. In addition, main additional key aspects of the problem are also presented and discussed. The results obtained and presented with the proposed approach show a very good agreement with available results from several similar high-fidelity projects, which encourages to continue to more complex problems and provides relevant insights for further developments and implementations.

    KW - High-fidelity multiphysics

    KW - Monte Carlo

    KW - Serpent 2

    KW - SUBCHANFLOW

    KW - VERA benchmark

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85059617150&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1016/j.anucene.2018.12.047

    DO - 10.1016/j.anucene.2018.12.047

    M3 - Article

    AN - SCOPUS:85059617150

    VL - 128

    SP - 102

    EP - 114

    JO - Annals of Nuclear Energy

    JF - Annals of Nuclear Energy

    SN - 0306-4549

    ER -