Status and experience with the technical basis and use of probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants

Phillippe Hessel, Jan-Erik Holmberg, Michael Knochenhauer, Abdallah Amri

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Probabilistic safety criteria, including safety goals, have been progressively introduced by regulatory bodies and utilities. They range from high level qualitative statements to technical criteria. They have been published in different ways, from legal documents to internal guides. They can be applied as legal limits down to “orientation values”. The OECD/NEA Working Group on Risk (WGRISK) prepared a questionnaire on the probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. Answers were received from 13 nuclear safety organizations and 6 utilities. The reported probabilistic risk criteria can be grouped into 4 categories, in relation with the tools to be used for assessing compliance: core damage frequency, releases frequency, frequency of doses and criteria on containment failure. Introduction of probabilistic safety criteria is generally considered to result in safety improvements. Opinion is widespread on the benefits of using probabilistic safety criteria for communication with the public, ranging from bad to good experiences. The responses to the questionnaire suggested that more work should be considered in the definition of releases frequencies: some regulators include a time range (generally 24 hours) in the criterion while others do not limit the time to be considered. It is suggested that, in the first case, the existing PSAs should be revisited to assess if long development accident sequences were considered.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of PSAM 10
Subtitle of host publicationInternational Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, 7–11 June 2010, Seattle, Washington, USA
PublisherInternational Association of Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management IAPSAM
Pages1074-1082
ISBN (Print)978-1-4507-1556-0
Publication statusPublished - 2010
MoE publication typeA4 Article in a conference publication
Event10th International Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, PSAM 10 - Seattle, United States
Duration: 7 Jun 201011 Jun 2010

Conference

Conference10th International Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, PSAM 10
Abbreviated titlePSAM 10
CountryUnited States
CitySeattle
Period7/06/1011/06/10

Fingerprint

Nuclear power plants
Accidents
Communication

Keywords

  • probabilistic safety criteria
  • risk criteria
  • safety goal
  • nuclear safety

Cite this

Hessel, P., Holmberg, J-E., Knochenhauer, M., & Amri, A. (2010). Status and experience with the technical basis and use of probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. In Proceedings of PSAM 10: International Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, 7–11 June 2010, Seattle, Washington, USA (pp. 1074-1082). International Association of Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management IAPSAM.
Hessel, Phillippe ; Holmberg, Jan-Erik ; Knochenhauer, Michael ; Amri, Abdallah. / Status and experience with the technical basis and use of probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. Proceedings of PSAM 10: International Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, 7–11 June 2010, Seattle, Washington, USA. International Association of Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management IAPSAM, 2010. pp. 1074-1082
@inproceedings{f836225fd3f648c9b150c0a57871daa2,
title = "Status and experience with the technical basis and use of probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants",
abstract = "Probabilistic safety criteria, including safety goals, have been progressively introduced by regulatory bodies and utilities. They range from high level qualitative statements to technical criteria. They have been published in different ways, from legal documents to internal guides. They can be applied as legal limits down to “orientation values”. The OECD/NEA Working Group on Risk (WGRISK) prepared a questionnaire on the probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. Answers were received from 13 nuclear safety organizations and 6 utilities. The reported probabilistic risk criteria can be grouped into 4 categories, in relation with the tools to be used for assessing compliance: core damage frequency, releases frequency, frequency of doses and criteria on containment failure. Introduction of probabilistic safety criteria is generally considered to result in safety improvements. Opinion is widespread on the benefits of using probabilistic safety criteria for communication with the public, ranging from bad to good experiences. The responses to the questionnaire suggested that more work should be considered in the definition of releases frequencies: some regulators include a time range (generally 24 hours) in the criterion while others do not limit the time to be considered. It is suggested that, in the first case, the existing PSAs should be revisited to assess if long development accident sequences were considered.",
keywords = "probabilistic safety criteria, risk criteria, safety goal, nuclear safety",
author = "Phillippe Hessel and Jan-Erik Holmberg and Michael Knochenhauer and Abdallah Amri",
note = "Proc. on a CD-Rom Project code: 41265-1.1",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-1-4507-1556-0",
pages = "1074--1082",
booktitle = "Proceedings of PSAM 10",
publisher = "International Association of Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management IAPSAM",
address = "United States",

}

Hessel, P, Holmberg, J-E, Knochenhauer, M & Amri, A 2010, Status and experience with the technical basis and use of probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. in Proceedings of PSAM 10: International Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, 7–11 June 2010, Seattle, Washington, USA. International Association of Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management IAPSAM, pp. 1074-1082, 10th International Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, PSAM 10, Seattle, United States, 7/06/10.

Status and experience with the technical basis and use of probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. / Hessel, Phillippe; Holmberg, Jan-Erik; Knochenhauer, Michael; Amri, Abdallah.

Proceedings of PSAM 10: International Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, 7–11 June 2010, Seattle, Washington, USA. International Association of Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management IAPSAM, 2010. p. 1074-1082.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientificpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Status and experience with the technical basis and use of probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants

AU - Hessel, Phillippe

AU - Holmberg, Jan-Erik

AU - Knochenhauer, Michael

AU - Amri, Abdallah

N1 - Proc. on a CD-Rom Project code: 41265-1.1

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - Probabilistic safety criteria, including safety goals, have been progressively introduced by regulatory bodies and utilities. They range from high level qualitative statements to technical criteria. They have been published in different ways, from legal documents to internal guides. They can be applied as legal limits down to “orientation values”. The OECD/NEA Working Group on Risk (WGRISK) prepared a questionnaire on the probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. Answers were received from 13 nuclear safety organizations and 6 utilities. The reported probabilistic risk criteria can be grouped into 4 categories, in relation with the tools to be used for assessing compliance: core damage frequency, releases frequency, frequency of doses and criteria on containment failure. Introduction of probabilistic safety criteria is generally considered to result in safety improvements. Opinion is widespread on the benefits of using probabilistic safety criteria for communication with the public, ranging from bad to good experiences. The responses to the questionnaire suggested that more work should be considered in the definition of releases frequencies: some regulators include a time range (generally 24 hours) in the criterion while others do not limit the time to be considered. It is suggested that, in the first case, the existing PSAs should be revisited to assess if long development accident sequences were considered.

AB - Probabilistic safety criteria, including safety goals, have been progressively introduced by regulatory bodies and utilities. They range from high level qualitative statements to technical criteria. They have been published in different ways, from legal documents to internal guides. They can be applied as legal limits down to “orientation values”. The OECD/NEA Working Group on Risk (WGRISK) prepared a questionnaire on the probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. Answers were received from 13 nuclear safety organizations and 6 utilities. The reported probabilistic risk criteria can be grouped into 4 categories, in relation with the tools to be used for assessing compliance: core damage frequency, releases frequency, frequency of doses and criteria on containment failure. Introduction of probabilistic safety criteria is generally considered to result in safety improvements. Opinion is widespread on the benefits of using probabilistic safety criteria for communication with the public, ranging from bad to good experiences. The responses to the questionnaire suggested that more work should be considered in the definition of releases frequencies: some regulators include a time range (generally 24 hours) in the criterion while others do not limit the time to be considered. It is suggested that, in the first case, the existing PSAs should be revisited to assess if long development accident sequences were considered.

KW - probabilistic safety criteria

KW - risk criteria

KW - safety goal

KW - nuclear safety

M3 - Conference article in proceedings

SN - 978-1-4507-1556-0

SP - 1074

EP - 1082

BT - Proceedings of PSAM 10

PB - International Association of Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management IAPSAM

ER -

Hessel P, Holmberg J-E, Knochenhauer M, Amri A. Status and experience with the technical basis and use of probabilistic risk criteria for nuclear power plants. In Proceedings of PSAM 10: International Probabilistic Safety Assessment & Management Conference, 7–11 June 2010, Seattle, Washington, USA. International Association of Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management IAPSAM. 2010. p. 1074-1082