The ISO 14067 approach to open-loop recycling of paper products: Making it operational

Catharina Hohenthal (Corresponding Author), Jorge Leon, Antonio Dobon, Marjukka Kujanpää, Gert Meinl, Jori Ringman, Mercedes Hortal, Ulla Forsström

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Allocating environmental impacts within life cycle assessment (LCA) is a recognised methodological problem. Different allocation methods have been developed to fulfil the various goals of LCA studies. At present, there is neither a consensus regarding the method to be used nor a one-fits-all method for dealing with recycling in LCA. The paper discusses some of the main allocation procedures practised in the pulp and paper industry, namely those covered by ISO/TS 14067:2018, GHG Protocol/PAS 2050, and the Product Environmental Footprint (PEF). All in all, the allocation method described in the ISO/TS 14067:2018 standard was considered the most appropriate to account for open-loop recycling of paper products. However, the method neither considers the number of subsequent uses of recycled fibres, nor the recycled fibre age. Yet, both of them are considered especially important in the open-loop recycling of paper products. In order to account for these aspects, the present study proposes an advanced, step-wise approach to handle allocation in LCAs accounting for the open-loop recycling of paper products. The advanced approach is based on the fibre mass flow model used to calculate the mean fibre age and the mean number of uses of paper products within the European context. The approach was validated with the data from the pulp and paper industry, particularly examining the newsprint paper grade with different contents of recycled fibre and fibre age. The paper, however, introduces all the parameters required to perform allocation based on the proposed method for other paper grades. The categpory of global warming potential was considered in the study as an illustrative example. yet the method could be applied to other impact assessment categories. The results calculated using the proposed allocation approach were compared to those obtained with the allocation methods described in the GHG Protocol/PAS 2050 and the PEF. The proposed allocation method can be used to guide further development of available standards and the product category rules, which will contribute to increased harmonisation and consistency of LCA studies in the pulp and paper sector, as well as to the enhanced practical implementation of LCA in industry.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)264-274
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of Cleaner Production
Volume224
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019
MoE publication typeNot Eligible

Fingerprint

Paper products
Recycling
recycling
Life cycle
Fibers
life cycle
Paper and pulp industry
pulp and paper industry
footprint
Newsprint
Global warming
Pulp
Environmental impact
product
paper
method
allocation
fibre
Fiber
global warming

Keywords

  • Allocation
  • Fibre age
  • Fibre flow model
  • Life cycle assessment
  • Number of uses
  • Open-loop recycling

Cite this

Hohenthal, Catharina ; Leon, Jorge ; Dobon, Antonio ; Kujanpää, Marjukka ; Meinl, Gert ; Ringman, Jori ; Hortal, Mercedes ; Forsström, Ulla. / The ISO 14067 approach to open-loop recycling of paper products : Making it operational. In: Journal of Cleaner Production. 2019 ; Vol. 224. pp. 264-274.
@article{2d13ca609f7a4e99b9935e12d33dc835,
title = "The ISO 14067 approach to open-loop recycling of paper products: Making it operational",
abstract = "Allocating environmental impacts within life cycle assessment (LCA) is a recognised methodological problem. Different allocation methods have been developed to fulfil the various goals of LCA studies. At present, there is neither a consensus regarding the method to be used nor a one-fits-all method for dealing with recycling in LCA. The paper discusses some of the main allocation procedures practised in the pulp and paper industry, namely those covered by ISO/TS 14067:2018, GHG Protocol/PAS 2050, and the Product Environmental Footprint (PEF). All in all, the allocation method described in the ISO/TS 14067:2018 standard was considered the most appropriate to account for open-loop recycling of paper products. However, the method neither considers the number of subsequent uses of recycled fibres, nor the recycled fibre age. Yet, both of them are considered especially important in the open-loop recycling of paper products. In order to account for these aspects, the present study proposes an advanced, step-wise approach to handle allocation in LCAs accounting for the open-loop recycling of paper products. The advanced approach is based on the fibre mass flow model used to calculate the mean fibre age and the mean number of uses of paper products within the European context. The approach was validated with the data from the pulp and paper industry, particularly examining the newsprint paper grade with different contents of recycled fibre and fibre age. The paper, however, introduces all the parameters required to perform allocation based on the proposed method for other paper grades. The categpory of global warming potential was considered in the study as an illustrative example. yet the method could be applied to other impact assessment categories. The results calculated using the proposed allocation approach were compared to those obtained with the allocation methods described in the GHG Protocol/PAS 2050 and the PEF. The proposed allocation method can be used to guide further development of available standards and the product category rules, which will contribute to increased harmonisation and consistency of LCA studies in the pulp and paper sector, as well as to the enhanced practical implementation of LCA in industry.",
keywords = "Allocation, Fibre age, Fibre flow model, Life cycle assessment, Number of uses, Open-loop recycling",
author = "Catharina Hohenthal and Jorge Leon and Antonio Dobon and Marjukka Kujanp{\"a}{\"a} and Gert Meinl and Jori Ringman and Mercedes Hortal and Ulla Forsstr{\"o}m",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.03.179",
language = "English",
volume = "224",
pages = "264--274",
journal = "Journal of Cleaner Production",
issn = "0959-6526",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

The ISO 14067 approach to open-loop recycling of paper products : Making it operational. / Hohenthal, Catharina (Corresponding Author); Leon, Jorge; Dobon, Antonio; Kujanpää, Marjukka; Meinl, Gert; Ringman, Jori; Hortal, Mercedes; Forsström, Ulla.

In: Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 224, 2019, p. 264-274.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The ISO 14067 approach to open-loop recycling of paper products

T2 - Making it operational

AU - Hohenthal, Catharina

AU - Leon, Jorge

AU - Dobon, Antonio

AU - Kujanpää, Marjukka

AU - Meinl, Gert

AU - Ringman, Jori

AU - Hortal, Mercedes

AU - Forsström, Ulla

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Allocating environmental impacts within life cycle assessment (LCA) is a recognised methodological problem. Different allocation methods have been developed to fulfil the various goals of LCA studies. At present, there is neither a consensus regarding the method to be used nor a one-fits-all method for dealing with recycling in LCA. The paper discusses some of the main allocation procedures practised in the pulp and paper industry, namely those covered by ISO/TS 14067:2018, GHG Protocol/PAS 2050, and the Product Environmental Footprint (PEF). All in all, the allocation method described in the ISO/TS 14067:2018 standard was considered the most appropriate to account for open-loop recycling of paper products. However, the method neither considers the number of subsequent uses of recycled fibres, nor the recycled fibre age. Yet, both of them are considered especially important in the open-loop recycling of paper products. In order to account for these aspects, the present study proposes an advanced, step-wise approach to handle allocation in LCAs accounting for the open-loop recycling of paper products. The advanced approach is based on the fibre mass flow model used to calculate the mean fibre age and the mean number of uses of paper products within the European context. The approach was validated with the data from the pulp and paper industry, particularly examining the newsprint paper grade with different contents of recycled fibre and fibre age. The paper, however, introduces all the parameters required to perform allocation based on the proposed method for other paper grades. The categpory of global warming potential was considered in the study as an illustrative example. yet the method could be applied to other impact assessment categories. The results calculated using the proposed allocation approach were compared to those obtained with the allocation methods described in the GHG Protocol/PAS 2050 and the PEF. The proposed allocation method can be used to guide further development of available standards and the product category rules, which will contribute to increased harmonisation and consistency of LCA studies in the pulp and paper sector, as well as to the enhanced practical implementation of LCA in industry.

AB - Allocating environmental impacts within life cycle assessment (LCA) is a recognised methodological problem. Different allocation methods have been developed to fulfil the various goals of LCA studies. At present, there is neither a consensus regarding the method to be used nor a one-fits-all method for dealing with recycling in LCA. The paper discusses some of the main allocation procedures practised in the pulp and paper industry, namely those covered by ISO/TS 14067:2018, GHG Protocol/PAS 2050, and the Product Environmental Footprint (PEF). All in all, the allocation method described in the ISO/TS 14067:2018 standard was considered the most appropriate to account for open-loop recycling of paper products. However, the method neither considers the number of subsequent uses of recycled fibres, nor the recycled fibre age. Yet, both of them are considered especially important in the open-loop recycling of paper products. In order to account for these aspects, the present study proposes an advanced, step-wise approach to handle allocation in LCAs accounting for the open-loop recycling of paper products. The advanced approach is based on the fibre mass flow model used to calculate the mean fibre age and the mean number of uses of paper products within the European context. The approach was validated with the data from the pulp and paper industry, particularly examining the newsprint paper grade with different contents of recycled fibre and fibre age. The paper, however, introduces all the parameters required to perform allocation based on the proposed method for other paper grades. The categpory of global warming potential was considered in the study as an illustrative example. yet the method could be applied to other impact assessment categories. The results calculated using the proposed allocation approach were compared to those obtained with the allocation methods described in the GHG Protocol/PAS 2050 and the PEF. The proposed allocation method can be used to guide further development of available standards and the product category rules, which will contribute to increased harmonisation and consistency of LCA studies in the pulp and paper sector, as well as to the enhanced practical implementation of LCA in industry.

KW - Allocation

KW - Fibre age

KW - Fibre flow model

KW - Life cycle assessment

KW - Number of uses

KW - Open-loop recycling

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85063567406&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.03.179

DO - 10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.03.179

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85063567406

VL - 224

SP - 264

EP - 274

JO - Journal of Cleaner Production

JF - Journal of Cleaner Production

SN - 0959-6526

ER -