Toroidal and poloidal momentum transport studies in JET

Tuomas Tala, Y. Andrew, K. Crombé, P.C. de Vries, X. Garbet, N. Hawkes, H. Nordman, Karin Rantamäki, et al

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    33 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    This paper reports on the recent studies of toroidal and poloidal momentum transport in JET. The ratio of the global energy confinement time to the momentum confinement is found to be close to τE/τphgr = 1 except for the low density or low collisionality discharges where the ratio is τE/τphgr = 2–3.
    On the other hand, local transport analysis of around 40 discharges shows that the ratio of the local effective momentum diffusivity to the ion heat diffusivity is χphgr/χi ≈ 0.1–0.4 (averaged over the radial region r/a = 0.4–0.7) rather than unity, as expected from the global confinement times and used often in ITER predictions.
    The apparent discrepancy in the global and local momentum versus ion heat transport can be at least partly explained by the fact that momentum confinement within edge pedestal is worse than that of the ion heat and thus, momentum pedestal is weaker than that of ion temperature.
    In addition, while the ion temperature profile shows clearly strong profile stiffness, the toroidal velocity profile does not exhibit stiffness, as exemplified here during a giant ELM crash. Predictive transport simulations with the self-consistent modelling of toroidal velocity using the Weiland model and GLF23 also confirm that the ratio χphgr/χi ≈ 0.4 reproduces the core toroidal velocity profiles well and similar accuracy with the ion temperature profiles.
    Concerning poloidal velocities on JET, the experimental measurements show that the carbon poloidal velocity can be an order of magnitude above the neo-classical estimate within the ITB.
    This significantly affects the calculated radial electric field and therefore, the E × B flow shear used for example in transport simulations. Both the Weiland model and GLF23 reproduce the onset, location and strength of the ITB well when the experimental poloidal velocity is used while they do not predict the formation of the ITB using the neo-classical poloidal velocity in time-dependent transport simulation.
    The most plausible explanation for the generation of the anomalous poloidal velocity is the turbulence driven flow through the Reynolds stress. Both CUTIE and TRB turbulence codes show the existence of an anomalous poloidal velocity, being significantly larger than the neo-classical values.
    And similarly to experiments, the poloidal velocity profiles peak in the vicinity of the ITB and seem to be dominantly caused by flow due to the Reynolds stress. However, it is important to note that both the codes treat the equilibrium in a simplified way and this affects the geodesic curvature effects and geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs). Therefore, the results should be considered as indicative, and most probably provide an upper bound of the mean poloidal velocity as results from other codes including GAM dynamics show that they often serve as a damping mechanism to flows.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)1012-1023
    JournalNuclear Fusion
    Volume47
    Issue number8
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2007
    MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

    Fingerprint

    momentum
    ion temperature
    velocity distribution
    Reynolds stress
    heat
    temperature profiles
    diffusivity
    stiffness
    turbulence
    crashes
    ions
    acoustics
    simulation
    shear flow
    unity
    damping
    curvature
    electric fields
    carbon
    estimates

    Keywords

    • toroidal momentum transport
    • poloidal momentum transport
    • plasma
    • Tokamak
    • JET
    • fusion energy
    • fusion reactors

    Cite this

    Tala, T., Andrew, Y., Crombé, K., de Vries, P. C., Garbet, X., Hawkes, N., ... al, E. (2007). Toroidal and poloidal momentum transport studies in JET. Nuclear Fusion, 47(8), 1012-1023. https://doi.org/10.1088/0029-5515/47/8/036
    Tala, Tuomas ; Andrew, Y. ; Crombé, K. ; de Vries, P.C. ; Garbet, X. ; Hawkes, N. ; Nordman, H. ; Rantamäki, Karin ; al, et. / Toroidal and poloidal momentum transport studies in JET. In: Nuclear Fusion. 2007 ; Vol. 47, No. 8. pp. 1012-1023.
    @article{923de7cb069c4678b7b4d226bb7840d1,
    title = "Toroidal and poloidal momentum transport studies in JET",
    abstract = "This paper reports on the recent studies of toroidal and poloidal momentum transport in JET. The ratio of the global energy confinement time to the momentum confinement is found to be close to τE/τphgr = 1 except for the low density or low collisionality discharges where the ratio is τE/τphgr = 2–3. On the other hand, local transport analysis of around 40 discharges shows that the ratio of the local effective momentum diffusivity to the ion heat diffusivity is χphgr/χi ≈ 0.1–0.4 (averaged over the radial region r/a = 0.4–0.7) rather than unity, as expected from the global confinement times and used often in ITER predictions. The apparent discrepancy in the global and local momentum versus ion heat transport can be at least partly explained by the fact that momentum confinement within edge pedestal is worse than that of the ion heat and thus, momentum pedestal is weaker than that of ion temperature. In addition, while the ion temperature profile shows clearly strong profile stiffness, the toroidal velocity profile does not exhibit stiffness, as exemplified here during a giant ELM crash. Predictive transport simulations with the self-consistent modelling of toroidal velocity using the Weiland model and GLF23 also confirm that the ratio χphgr/χi ≈ 0.4 reproduces the core toroidal velocity profiles well and similar accuracy with the ion temperature profiles. Concerning poloidal velocities on JET, the experimental measurements show that the carbon poloidal velocity can be an order of magnitude above the neo-classical estimate within the ITB. This significantly affects the calculated radial electric field and therefore, the E × B flow shear used for example in transport simulations. Both the Weiland model and GLF23 reproduce the onset, location and strength of the ITB well when the experimental poloidal velocity is used while they do not predict the formation of the ITB using the neo-classical poloidal velocity in time-dependent transport simulation. The most plausible explanation for the generation of the anomalous poloidal velocity is the turbulence driven flow through the Reynolds stress. Both CUTIE and TRB turbulence codes show the existence of an anomalous poloidal velocity, being significantly larger than the neo-classical values. And similarly to experiments, the poloidal velocity profiles peak in the vicinity of the ITB and seem to be dominantly caused by flow due to the Reynolds stress. However, it is important to note that both the codes treat the equilibrium in a simplified way and this affects the geodesic curvature effects and geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs). Therefore, the results should be considered as indicative, and most probably provide an upper bound of the mean poloidal velocity as results from other codes including GAM dynamics show that they often serve as a damping mechanism to flows.",
    keywords = "toroidal momentum transport, poloidal momentum transport, plasma, Tokamak, JET, fusion energy, fusion reactors",
    author = "Tuomas Tala and Y. Andrew and K. Cromb{\'e} and {de Vries}, P.C. and X. Garbet and N. Hawkes and H. Nordman and Karin Rantam{\"a}ki and et al",
    year = "2007",
    doi = "10.1088/0029-5515/47/8/036",
    language = "English",
    volume = "47",
    pages = "1012--1023",
    journal = "Nuclear Fusion",
    issn = "0029-5515",
    publisher = "Institute of Physics IOP",
    number = "8",

    }

    Tala, T, Andrew, Y, Crombé, K, de Vries, PC, Garbet, X, Hawkes, N, Nordman, H, Rantamäki, K & al, E 2007, 'Toroidal and poloidal momentum transport studies in JET', Nuclear Fusion, vol. 47, no. 8, pp. 1012-1023. https://doi.org/10.1088/0029-5515/47/8/036

    Toroidal and poloidal momentum transport studies in JET. / Tala, Tuomas; Andrew, Y.; Crombé, K.; de Vries, P.C.; Garbet, X.; Hawkes, N.; Nordman, H.; Rantamäki, Karin; al, et.

    In: Nuclear Fusion, Vol. 47, No. 8, 2007, p. 1012-1023.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Toroidal and poloidal momentum transport studies in JET

    AU - Tala, Tuomas

    AU - Andrew, Y.

    AU - Crombé, K.

    AU - de Vries, P.C.

    AU - Garbet, X.

    AU - Hawkes, N.

    AU - Nordman, H.

    AU - Rantamäki, Karin

    AU - al, et

    PY - 2007

    Y1 - 2007

    N2 - This paper reports on the recent studies of toroidal and poloidal momentum transport in JET. The ratio of the global energy confinement time to the momentum confinement is found to be close to τE/τphgr = 1 except for the low density or low collisionality discharges where the ratio is τE/τphgr = 2–3. On the other hand, local transport analysis of around 40 discharges shows that the ratio of the local effective momentum diffusivity to the ion heat diffusivity is χphgr/χi ≈ 0.1–0.4 (averaged over the radial region r/a = 0.4–0.7) rather than unity, as expected from the global confinement times and used often in ITER predictions. The apparent discrepancy in the global and local momentum versus ion heat transport can be at least partly explained by the fact that momentum confinement within edge pedestal is worse than that of the ion heat and thus, momentum pedestal is weaker than that of ion temperature. In addition, while the ion temperature profile shows clearly strong profile stiffness, the toroidal velocity profile does not exhibit stiffness, as exemplified here during a giant ELM crash. Predictive transport simulations with the self-consistent modelling of toroidal velocity using the Weiland model and GLF23 also confirm that the ratio χphgr/χi ≈ 0.4 reproduces the core toroidal velocity profiles well and similar accuracy with the ion temperature profiles. Concerning poloidal velocities on JET, the experimental measurements show that the carbon poloidal velocity can be an order of magnitude above the neo-classical estimate within the ITB. This significantly affects the calculated radial electric field and therefore, the E × B flow shear used for example in transport simulations. Both the Weiland model and GLF23 reproduce the onset, location and strength of the ITB well when the experimental poloidal velocity is used while they do not predict the formation of the ITB using the neo-classical poloidal velocity in time-dependent transport simulation. The most plausible explanation for the generation of the anomalous poloidal velocity is the turbulence driven flow through the Reynolds stress. Both CUTIE and TRB turbulence codes show the existence of an anomalous poloidal velocity, being significantly larger than the neo-classical values. And similarly to experiments, the poloidal velocity profiles peak in the vicinity of the ITB and seem to be dominantly caused by flow due to the Reynolds stress. However, it is important to note that both the codes treat the equilibrium in a simplified way and this affects the geodesic curvature effects and geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs). Therefore, the results should be considered as indicative, and most probably provide an upper bound of the mean poloidal velocity as results from other codes including GAM dynamics show that they often serve as a damping mechanism to flows.

    AB - This paper reports on the recent studies of toroidal and poloidal momentum transport in JET. The ratio of the global energy confinement time to the momentum confinement is found to be close to τE/τphgr = 1 except for the low density or low collisionality discharges where the ratio is τE/τphgr = 2–3. On the other hand, local transport analysis of around 40 discharges shows that the ratio of the local effective momentum diffusivity to the ion heat diffusivity is χphgr/χi ≈ 0.1–0.4 (averaged over the radial region r/a = 0.4–0.7) rather than unity, as expected from the global confinement times and used often in ITER predictions. The apparent discrepancy in the global and local momentum versus ion heat transport can be at least partly explained by the fact that momentum confinement within edge pedestal is worse than that of the ion heat and thus, momentum pedestal is weaker than that of ion temperature. In addition, while the ion temperature profile shows clearly strong profile stiffness, the toroidal velocity profile does not exhibit stiffness, as exemplified here during a giant ELM crash. Predictive transport simulations with the self-consistent modelling of toroidal velocity using the Weiland model and GLF23 also confirm that the ratio χphgr/χi ≈ 0.4 reproduces the core toroidal velocity profiles well and similar accuracy with the ion temperature profiles. Concerning poloidal velocities on JET, the experimental measurements show that the carbon poloidal velocity can be an order of magnitude above the neo-classical estimate within the ITB. This significantly affects the calculated radial electric field and therefore, the E × B flow shear used for example in transport simulations. Both the Weiland model and GLF23 reproduce the onset, location and strength of the ITB well when the experimental poloidal velocity is used while they do not predict the formation of the ITB using the neo-classical poloidal velocity in time-dependent transport simulation. The most plausible explanation for the generation of the anomalous poloidal velocity is the turbulence driven flow through the Reynolds stress. Both CUTIE and TRB turbulence codes show the existence of an anomalous poloidal velocity, being significantly larger than the neo-classical values. And similarly to experiments, the poloidal velocity profiles peak in the vicinity of the ITB and seem to be dominantly caused by flow due to the Reynolds stress. However, it is important to note that both the codes treat the equilibrium in a simplified way and this affects the geodesic curvature effects and geodesic acoustic modes (GAMs). Therefore, the results should be considered as indicative, and most probably provide an upper bound of the mean poloidal velocity as results from other codes including GAM dynamics show that they often serve as a damping mechanism to flows.

    KW - toroidal momentum transport

    KW - poloidal momentum transport

    KW - plasma

    KW - Tokamak

    KW - JET

    KW - fusion energy

    KW - fusion reactors

    U2 - 10.1088/0029-5515/47/8/036

    DO - 10.1088/0029-5515/47/8/036

    M3 - Article

    VL - 47

    SP - 1012

    EP - 1023

    JO - Nuclear Fusion

    JF - Nuclear Fusion

    SN - 0029-5515

    IS - 8

    ER -

    Tala T, Andrew Y, Crombé K, de Vries PC, Garbet X, Hawkes N et al. Toroidal and poloidal momentum transport studies in JET. Nuclear Fusion. 2007;47(8):1012-1023. https://doi.org/10.1088/0029-5515/47/8/036