Validation of a new measuring system for water turbidity field measurements

Teemu Näykki (Corresponding Author), Sampsa Koponen, Tero Väisänen, Timo Pyhälahti, Timo Toivanen, Ivo Leito

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Turbidity is an essential parameter for describing water quality by direct and indirect impacts on fish, invertebrates and aquatic plants. Currently, environmental monitoring measurements are carried out with appropriate quality by accredited testing laboratories, but there is also a need for employing the third sector, i.e. citizens and voluntaries in environmental monitoring. A device called "Secchi3000" was developed as a low-cost and simple-to-operate tool so that water quality measurements can also be carried out by non-experts and citizens. The measurement using the new device is simple: The user fills the container with water and places the measurement structure in the container. The user takes a photograph with the camera on a mobile phone through a hole in the lid. The software sends the photograph to a server, which analyses the photographs automatically. Finally, the results are returned to the user's mobile phone and stored on a database for further analysis. In this study, the measuring system for turbidity measurements in natural waters was validated. Validation included an estimation of the limit of quantification, investigations of the influence of water colour and illumination conditions on turbidity measurement values and the estimation of measurement uncertainty. A comparison of turbidity results obtained with the new device and laboratory instrument in natural water samples was carried out, and turbidity values obtained with different mobile phones were compared. According to the validation results, the new device was appropriate for the measurement of turbidity lower than 7 FNU (Formazine Nephelometric Unit). An algorithm applied for present turbidity calculations is not fully suitable for higher turbidities. For potential routine use, this is not a major problem, since most Finnish natural waters have turbidities lower than 7 FNU. For official monitoring purposes, the limit of the quantification needs to be lower than presently achieved (1.7 FNU). Although the present configuration of the Secchi3000 device is not yet fully suitable for official environmental monitoring, it will already enable the involvement of the third sector in water quality monitoring, and in this way, citizens' observations could then serve at least as supplementary information for reporting and surveys.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)175-183
JournalAccreditation and Quality Assurance
Volume19
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014
MoE publication typeA1 Journal article-refereed

Fingerprint

turbidity
Turbidity
Water
water
water quality
environmental monitoring
photographs
Mobile phones
Monitoring
Water quality
containers
Containers
water color
aquatic plants
sectors
invertebrates
fishes
Fish
Servers
Lighting

Keywords

  • turbidity
  • water quality
  • quality monitoring

Cite this

Näykki, T., Koponen, S., Väisänen, T., Pyhälahti, T., Toivanen, T., & Leito, I. (2014). Validation of a new measuring system for water turbidity field measurements. Accreditation and Quality Assurance, 19(3), 175-183. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00769-014-1052-9
Näykki, Teemu ; Koponen, Sampsa ; Väisänen, Tero ; Pyhälahti, Timo ; Toivanen, Timo ; Leito, Ivo. / Validation of a new measuring system for water turbidity field measurements. In: Accreditation and Quality Assurance. 2014 ; Vol. 19, No. 3. pp. 175-183.
@article{a2ab003b6f4046dfa010d2784e396bc5,
title = "Validation of a new measuring system for water turbidity field measurements",
abstract = "Turbidity is an essential parameter for describing water quality by direct and indirect impacts on fish, invertebrates and aquatic plants. Currently, environmental monitoring measurements are carried out with appropriate quality by accredited testing laboratories, but there is also a need for employing the third sector, i.e. citizens and voluntaries in environmental monitoring. A device called {"}Secchi3000{"} was developed as a low-cost and simple-to-operate tool so that water quality measurements can also be carried out by non-experts and citizens. The measurement using the new device is simple: The user fills the container with water and places the measurement structure in the container. The user takes a photograph with the camera on a mobile phone through a hole in the lid. The software sends the photograph to a server, which analyses the photographs automatically. Finally, the results are returned to the user's mobile phone and stored on a database for further analysis. In this study, the measuring system for turbidity measurements in natural waters was validated. Validation included an estimation of the limit of quantification, investigations of the influence of water colour and illumination conditions on turbidity measurement values and the estimation of measurement uncertainty. A comparison of turbidity results obtained with the new device and laboratory instrument in natural water samples was carried out, and turbidity values obtained with different mobile phones were compared. According to the validation results, the new device was appropriate for the measurement of turbidity lower than 7 FNU (Formazine Nephelometric Unit). An algorithm applied for present turbidity calculations is not fully suitable for higher turbidities. For potential routine use, this is not a major problem, since most Finnish natural waters have turbidities lower than 7 FNU. For official monitoring purposes, the limit of the quantification needs to be lower than presently achieved (1.7 FNU). Although the present configuration of the Secchi3000 device is not yet fully suitable for official environmental monitoring, it will already enable the involvement of the third sector in water quality monitoring, and in this way, citizens' observations could then serve at least as supplementary information for reporting and surveys.",
keywords = "turbidity, water quality, quality monitoring",
author = "Teemu N{\"a}ykki and Sampsa Koponen and Tero V{\"a}is{\"a}nen and Timo Pyh{\"a}lahti and Timo Toivanen and Ivo Leito",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1007/s00769-014-1052-9",
language = "English",
volume = "19",
pages = "175--183",
journal = "Accreditation and Quality Assurance",
issn = "0949-1775",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "3",

}

Näykki, T, Koponen, S, Väisänen, T, Pyhälahti, T, Toivanen, T & Leito, I 2014, 'Validation of a new measuring system for water turbidity field measurements', Accreditation and Quality Assurance, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 175-183. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00769-014-1052-9

Validation of a new measuring system for water turbidity field measurements. / Näykki, Teemu (Corresponding Author); Koponen, Sampsa; Väisänen, Tero; Pyhälahti, Timo; Toivanen, Timo; Leito, Ivo.

In: Accreditation and Quality Assurance, Vol. 19, No. 3, 2014, p. 175-183.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Validation of a new measuring system for water turbidity field measurements

AU - Näykki, Teemu

AU - Koponen, Sampsa

AU - Väisänen, Tero

AU - Pyhälahti, Timo

AU - Toivanen, Timo

AU - Leito, Ivo

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - Turbidity is an essential parameter for describing water quality by direct and indirect impacts on fish, invertebrates and aquatic plants. Currently, environmental monitoring measurements are carried out with appropriate quality by accredited testing laboratories, but there is also a need for employing the third sector, i.e. citizens and voluntaries in environmental monitoring. A device called "Secchi3000" was developed as a low-cost and simple-to-operate tool so that water quality measurements can also be carried out by non-experts and citizens. The measurement using the new device is simple: The user fills the container with water and places the measurement structure in the container. The user takes a photograph with the camera on a mobile phone through a hole in the lid. The software sends the photograph to a server, which analyses the photographs automatically. Finally, the results are returned to the user's mobile phone and stored on a database for further analysis. In this study, the measuring system for turbidity measurements in natural waters was validated. Validation included an estimation of the limit of quantification, investigations of the influence of water colour and illumination conditions on turbidity measurement values and the estimation of measurement uncertainty. A comparison of turbidity results obtained with the new device and laboratory instrument in natural water samples was carried out, and turbidity values obtained with different mobile phones were compared. According to the validation results, the new device was appropriate for the measurement of turbidity lower than 7 FNU (Formazine Nephelometric Unit). An algorithm applied for present turbidity calculations is not fully suitable for higher turbidities. For potential routine use, this is not a major problem, since most Finnish natural waters have turbidities lower than 7 FNU. For official monitoring purposes, the limit of the quantification needs to be lower than presently achieved (1.7 FNU). Although the present configuration of the Secchi3000 device is not yet fully suitable for official environmental monitoring, it will already enable the involvement of the third sector in water quality monitoring, and in this way, citizens' observations could then serve at least as supplementary information for reporting and surveys.

AB - Turbidity is an essential parameter for describing water quality by direct and indirect impacts on fish, invertebrates and aquatic plants. Currently, environmental monitoring measurements are carried out with appropriate quality by accredited testing laboratories, but there is also a need for employing the third sector, i.e. citizens and voluntaries in environmental monitoring. A device called "Secchi3000" was developed as a low-cost and simple-to-operate tool so that water quality measurements can also be carried out by non-experts and citizens. The measurement using the new device is simple: The user fills the container with water and places the measurement structure in the container. The user takes a photograph with the camera on a mobile phone through a hole in the lid. The software sends the photograph to a server, which analyses the photographs automatically. Finally, the results are returned to the user's mobile phone and stored on a database for further analysis. In this study, the measuring system for turbidity measurements in natural waters was validated. Validation included an estimation of the limit of quantification, investigations of the influence of water colour and illumination conditions on turbidity measurement values and the estimation of measurement uncertainty. A comparison of turbidity results obtained with the new device and laboratory instrument in natural water samples was carried out, and turbidity values obtained with different mobile phones were compared. According to the validation results, the new device was appropriate for the measurement of turbidity lower than 7 FNU (Formazine Nephelometric Unit). An algorithm applied for present turbidity calculations is not fully suitable for higher turbidities. For potential routine use, this is not a major problem, since most Finnish natural waters have turbidities lower than 7 FNU. For official monitoring purposes, the limit of the quantification needs to be lower than presently achieved (1.7 FNU). Although the present configuration of the Secchi3000 device is not yet fully suitable for official environmental monitoring, it will already enable the involvement of the third sector in water quality monitoring, and in this way, citizens' observations could then serve at least as supplementary information for reporting and surveys.

KW - turbidity

KW - water quality

KW - quality monitoring

U2 - 10.1007/s00769-014-1052-9

DO - 10.1007/s00769-014-1052-9

M3 - Article

VL - 19

SP - 175

EP - 183

JO - Accreditation and Quality Assurance

JF - Accreditation and Quality Assurance

SN - 0949-1775

IS - 3

ER -