Virtual Reality for Meeting Interaction in Infrastructure Construction Project

Janne Porkka, Timo Kuula, K. Kähkönen, J. Rannisto

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Urban planning and infrastructure projects of varied sizes are increasingly utilizing model-based applications at planning phase. Although the use of virtual models has its advantages, there are multiple challenges that diminish their potential in project use. These challenges are related to either non-human or human topics. The non-human topics cover issues like deficient processes, practices and tools. The human-related topics include for example lack of communication and interaction between relevant stakeholders. The interaction is a key element in current design practice due to the high number of disciplines involved in design formation and decision-making. During the past years, many key stakeholders have experienced difficulties in changing the current way of working with model-based practices. Virtual reality (VR) has been found to offer promise for design visualisation to convey messages with reduced communication difficulties between stakeholders. This paper draws findings from observations in one meeting at an on-going large infrastructure construction project in Finland. In this case study, virtual reality has been used in project management meetings to facilitate communication and to support decision-making. We consider how the use of virtual reality actually influenced on group dynamics and make concluding remarks underpinning the use in a traditional meeting room environment. We have used activity theory as a framework to begin method development for observing and analysing the effects of virtual reality on interaction and related work practices. The empirical findings point out, that new visualization instruments have effects on the 'division of labour'. Following five traditional meeting interaction characteristics showed changes at group dynamics. When virtual reality was used as a presentation tool, the interaction between participants became more balanced. Activation of all participants, most probably, leads to enhanced mutual understanding, and furthermore to better results in the whole project.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of 13th International Conference on Construction Application of Virtual Reality
Subtitle of host publicationCONVR 2013
EditorsN. Dawood, M. Kassem
Pages354-362
Publication statusPublished - 2013
MoE publication typeNot Eligible
Event13th International Conference on Construction Applications of Virtual Reality, CONVR 2013 - London, United Kingdom
Duration: 30 Oct 201331 Oct 2013

Conference

Conference13th International Conference on Construction Applications of Virtual Reality, CONVR 2013
Abbreviated titleCONVR 2013
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityLondon
Period30/10/1331/10/13

Fingerprint

Virtual reality
Communication
Visualization
Decision making
Urban planning
Project management
Chemical activation
Personnel
Planning

Keywords

  • infrastructure construction
  • virtual reality
  • meeting
  • interaction
  • decision making

Cite this

Porkka, J., Kuula, T., Kähkönen, K., & Rannisto, J. (2013). Virtual Reality for Meeting Interaction in Infrastructure Construction Project. In N. Dawood, & M. Kassem (Eds.), Proceedings of 13th International Conference on Construction Application of Virtual Reality: CONVR 2013 (pp. 354-362)
Porkka, Janne ; Kuula, Timo ; Kähkönen, K. ; Rannisto, J. / Virtual Reality for Meeting Interaction in Infrastructure Construction Project. Proceedings of 13th International Conference on Construction Application of Virtual Reality: CONVR 2013. editor / N. Dawood ; M. Kassem. 2013. pp. 354-362
@inproceedings{ae07d91af1e34765aead59335ab8ed03,
title = "Virtual Reality for Meeting Interaction in Infrastructure Construction Project",
abstract = "Urban planning and infrastructure projects of varied sizes are increasingly utilizing model-based applications at planning phase. Although the use of virtual models has its advantages, there are multiple challenges that diminish their potential in project use. These challenges are related to either non-human or human topics. The non-human topics cover issues like deficient processes, practices and tools. The human-related topics include for example lack of communication and interaction between relevant stakeholders. The interaction is a key element in current design practice due to the high number of disciplines involved in design formation and decision-making. During the past years, many key stakeholders have experienced difficulties in changing the current way of working with model-based practices. Virtual reality (VR) has been found to offer promise for design visualisation to convey messages with reduced communication difficulties between stakeholders. This paper draws findings from observations in one meeting at an on-going large infrastructure construction project in Finland. In this case study, virtual reality has been used in project management meetings to facilitate communication and to support decision-making. We consider how the use of virtual reality actually influenced on group dynamics and make concluding remarks underpinning the use in a traditional meeting room environment. We have used activity theory as a framework to begin method development for observing and analysing the effects of virtual reality on interaction and related work practices. The empirical findings point out, that new visualization instruments have effects on the 'division of labour'. Following five traditional meeting interaction characteristics showed changes at group dynamics. When virtual reality was used as a presentation tool, the interaction between participants became more balanced. Activation of all participants, most probably, leads to enhanced mutual understanding, and furthermore to better results in the whole project.",
keywords = "infrastructure construction, virtual reality, meeting, interaction, decision making",
author = "Janne Porkka and Timo Kuula and K. K{\"a}hk{\"o}nen and J. Rannisto",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-0-9927161-0-3",
pages = "354--362",
editor = "N. Dawood and M. Kassem",
booktitle = "Proceedings of 13th International Conference on Construction Application of Virtual Reality",

}

Porkka, J, Kuula, T, Kähkönen, K & Rannisto, J 2013, Virtual Reality for Meeting Interaction in Infrastructure Construction Project. in N Dawood & M Kassem (eds), Proceedings of 13th International Conference on Construction Application of Virtual Reality: CONVR 2013. pp. 354-362, 13th International Conference on Construction Applications of Virtual Reality, CONVR 2013, London, United Kingdom, 30/10/13.

Virtual Reality for Meeting Interaction in Infrastructure Construction Project. / Porkka, Janne; Kuula, Timo; Kähkönen, K.; Rannisto, J.

Proceedings of 13th International Conference on Construction Application of Virtual Reality: CONVR 2013. ed. / N. Dawood; M. Kassem. 2013. p. 354-362.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference article in proceedingsScientificpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Virtual Reality for Meeting Interaction in Infrastructure Construction Project

AU - Porkka, Janne

AU - Kuula, Timo

AU - Kähkönen, K.

AU - Rannisto, J.

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Urban planning and infrastructure projects of varied sizes are increasingly utilizing model-based applications at planning phase. Although the use of virtual models has its advantages, there are multiple challenges that diminish their potential in project use. These challenges are related to either non-human or human topics. The non-human topics cover issues like deficient processes, practices and tools. The human-related topics include for example lack of communication and interaction between relevant stakeholders. The interaction is a key element in current design practice due to the high number of disciplines involved in design formation and decision-making. During the past years, many key stakeholders have experienced difficulties in changing the current way of working with model-based practices. Virtual reality (VR) has been found to offer promise for design visualisation to convey messages with reduced communication difficulties between stakeholders. This paper draws findings from observations in one meeting at an on-going large infrastructure construction project in Finland. In this case study, virtual reality has been used in project management meetings to facilitate communication and to support decision-making. We consider how the use of virtual reality actually influenced on group dynamics and make concluding remarks underpinning the use in a traditional meeting room environment. We have used activity theory as a framework to begin method development for observing and analysing the effects of virtual reality on interaction and related work practices. The empirical findings point out, that new visualization instruments have effects on the 'division of labour'. Following five traditional meeting interaction characteristics showed changes at group dynamics. When virtual reality was used as a presentation tool, the interaction between participants became more balanced. Activation of all participants, most probably, leads to enhanced mutual understanding, and furthermore to better results in the whole project.

AB - Urban planning and infrastructure projects of varied sizes are increasingly utilizing model-based applications at planning phase. Although the use of virtual models has its advantages, there are multiple challenges that diminish their potential in project use. These challenges are related to either non-human or human topics. The non-human topics cover issues like deficient processes, practices and tools. The human-related topics include for example lack of communication and interaction between relevant stakeholders. The interaction is a key element in current design practice due to the high number of disciplines involved in design formation and decision-making. During the past years, many key stakeholders have experienced difficulties in changing the current way of working with model-based practices. Virtual reality (VR) has been found to offer promise for design visualisation to convey messages with reduced communication difficulties between stakeholders. This paper draws findings from observations in one meeting at an on-going large infrastructure construction project in Finland. In this case study, virtual reality has been used in project management meetings to facilitate communication and to support decision-making. We consider how the use of virtual reality actually influenced on group dynamics and make concluding remarks underpinning the use in a traditional meeting room environment. We have used activity theory as a framework to begin method development for observing and analysing the effects of virtual reality on interaction and related work practices. The empirical findings point out, that new visualization instruments have effects on the 'division of labour'. Following five traditional meeting interaction characteristics showed changes at group dynamics. When virtual reality was used as a presentation tool, the interaction between participants became more balanced. Activation of all participants, most probably, leads to enhanced mutual understanding, and furthermore to better results in the whole project.

KW - infrastructure construction

KW - virtual reality

KW - meeting

KW - interaction

KW - decision making

M3 - Conference article in proceedings

SN - 978-0-9927161-0-3

SP - 354

EP - 362

BT - Proceedings of 13th International Conference on Construction Application of Virtual Reality

A2 - Dawood, N.

A2 - Kassem, M.

ER -

Porkka J, Kuula T, Kähkönen K, Rannisto J. Virtual Reality for Meeting Interaction in Infrastructure Construction Project. In Dawood N, Kassem M, editors, Proceedings of 13th International Conference on Construction Application of Virtual Reality: CONVR 2013. 2013. p. 354-362